5D Mark III - First 24 Hours Review (post yours here!)

1679111214

Comments

  • OverfocusedOverfocused Registered Users Posts: 1,068 Major grins
    edited April 15, 2012
    Diggin #2
  • kdogkdog Administrators Posts: 11,680 moderator
    edited April 15, 2012
    Here's some more 5D3 photos for my Dgrin amigos.
    Awesome shots. thumb.gifthumb.gif
  • David_S85David_S85 Administrators Posts: 13,167 moderator
    edited April 16, 2012
    Josh, those are beautiful shots!
    My Smugmug
    "You miss 100% of the shots you don't take" - Wayne Gretzky
  • nw scoutnw scout Registered Users Posts: 256 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    Put my 5D Mark3 to the test today at the track mwink.gif

    i-nrfnqTQ-L.jpg


    Still have 1,000 or so shots to go through before I have a better idea on how it worked.
    But in general the focus for sure seems a lot better. I have to get used to some of the controls as they are so much different. Nothing major, just will take some getting used to.

    The shutter sounds really weird. Way different than any camera I have ever used. Almost sounds broken or loose. The few images I have looked at seem nice up to 50% then kinda fall apart after that so Im not liking that at all. Not sure what is going on yet, but like I said, I have a lot of images to go through so I hope I can figure it out?
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    nw scout wrote: »
    Put my 5D Mark3 to the test today at the track mwink.gif

    Good looking MX shot! What do you mean when you say you don't like the 5D3 images at 50% or greater?
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    Here's an out of camera S1 JPG from tonight's sunset. 5D3, 85 1.2L, Emerald profile with lots of amber/magenta WB shift.

    JMP16663-X2.jpg
  • jmphotocraftjmphotocraft Registered Users Posts: 2,987 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    nw scout wrote: »
    The few images I have looked at seem nice up to 50% then kinda fall apart after that so Im not liking that at all. Not sure what is going on yet, but like I said, I have a lot of images to go through so I hope I can figure it out?

    Maybe your AF needs calibration, either by micro focus adjustment, or by Canon Service. I'm finding my 5D3 to be just as enjoyable to pixel peep as my 5D2, and more often due to the better AF.

    See this thread for a couple of my action shots with 100% crops:
    http://www.dgrin.com/showthread.php?t=217762

    My 7D was a different story. Compared to the 5D2 (and 3), which isn't really a fair fight, viewing at 100% just wasn't usually satisfying. I had to learn to judge 7D images at 50%. My 5D3 is not like that at all.
    -Jack

    An "accurate" reproduction of a scene and a good photograph are often two different things.
  • nw scoutnw scout Registered Users Posts: 256 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    Good looking MX shot! What do you mean when you say you don't like the 5D3 images at 50% or greater?

    Its weird. It looks raserized? Not sure thats the right term for the look but its not smooth tones and the edges look very digital. Not a focus issue and its the same look at 100 to 400 asa.

    Also got lots of errors. No error #, just an Err and it stopped working.
    Turned if off and on then it was fine till it did it again. Only did it in auto focus mode, but not sure if that means anything as I was in AF mode most of the day testing all the new settings.

    i-Hmfh7HN-L.jpg
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    nw scout wrote: »
    Its weird. It looks raserized? Not sure thats the right term for the look but its not smooth tones and the edges look very digital. Not a focus issue and its the same look at 100 to 400 asa

    What raw converter are you using? Try shooting some L JPEG's and see how those look.
  • jmphotocraftjmphotocraft Registered Users Posts: 2,987 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    nw scout wrote: »
    Its weird. It looks raserized? Not sure thats the right term for the look but its not smooth tones and the edges look very digital. Not a focus issue and its the same look at 100 to 400 asa.

    Are you using DPP? If not, try it. If so, change the RAW sharpening method from "Unsharp Mask" to "Sharpness", I like that better.
    Also got lots of errors. No error #, just an Err and it stopped working.
    Turned if off and on then it was fine till it did it again. Only did it in auto focus mode, but not sure if that means anything as I was in AF mode most of the day testing all the new settings.

    Sounds very fishy, I'd take/send the camera back to where you bought it. No errors with my 5D3, and the images are stunning at 100% in DPP.
    -Jack

    An "accurate" reproduction of a scene and a good photograph are often two different things.
  • OverfocusedOverfocused Registered Users Posts: 1,068 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    Sounds very fishy, I'd take/send the camera back to where you bought it. No errors with my 5D3, and the images are stunning at 100% in DPP.

    this nod.gif
  • nw scoutnw scout Registered Users Posts: 256 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    Ha.
    I was at the store doing just that (returning it) a little while ago.
    Home now with the new one. Will do some testing later and let ya all know how it goes.
  • Matthew SavilleMatthew Saville Registered Users, Retired Mod Posts: 3,352 Major grins
    edited April 16, 2012
    Studio shot it's 2nd wedding with the 5D mk3, and for a second time the lead shooter decided there was a SIGNIFICANT issue with "focus confirmation hesitance". In fact this lead shooter even switched back to the mk2 for a little while just to be sure they weren't just imagining the difference.

    Hopefully we just have a lemon? We'll approach Canon about the issue, since the studio is right down the street from CPS...

    (Although, once again I'd like to emphasize, there is a SIGNIFICANT improvement in the keeper, in-focus rate. It just hesitates a little bit before confirming focus, which is noticeable enough to cause worries about missing candid moments...


    =Matt=
    My first thought is always of light.” – Galen Rowell
    My SmugMug PortfolioMy Astro-Landscape Photo BlogDgrin Weddings Forum
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    Studio shot it's 2nd wedding with the 5D mk3, and for a second time the lead shooter decided there was a SIGNIFICANT issue with "focus confirmation hesitance"....

    =Matt=

    I can replicate the same issue, and here's the fix:
    • Use one of the TWO Single Point AF modes
    • Do NOT use any mode that requires the camera to select the AF point
    • Consider whether or not your comparing to situations in which the 5D2 would say "focused!", when it was really "close enough!"

    Same goes for AI-Servo usage. I have not found the AF Point tracking to be all that impressive. I get better results in AI servo mode my using one of the Single Point or "cluster" AF Point modes. But I am hard to please. The D700 AF Point tracking didn't even make my cut. The D3s or 1DMK4 are the only bodies with AF point tracking that is really snappy enough to rely on...for me. The good news is the 5D3 has the processing power for this to work well, I would expect firmware updates to help out in this regard. Better written algorithms for the AF point tracking/selection would make things more responsive.
  • OverfocusedOverfocused Registered Users Posts: 1,068 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    Has anyone tried the different shot priority and AI focusing mode combinations yet? All of the different AI focus modes? They do significantly change the behavior of it and most people seem to be going on the standard mode and not going over the other AF scenarios....

    Better written algorithms for the AF point tracking/selection would make things more responsive.




    The AI servo behavior settings are the algorithms changeable at our disposal... did you change those yet? It sounds like you've only tried the AF point selection modes and left out the AI servo behavior settings. Standard mode is a little slow and changing the settings dramatically changes the behavior.

    A lot of these problems are in the dark so if it keeps up I imagine something indeed will have to be changed by Canon in order to reduce that delay in the dark. I've still yet to do a low light shoot, so hopefully soon I'll be able to do this first person. So far no problems though.
  • OverfocusedOverfocused Registered Users Posts: 1,068 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    And uh, forgot to ask... how dark are we talkin'? I haven't seen any examples of the scenarios people say they're having the problem with.
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    The AI/servo tracking modes are the algorithms changeable at our disposal... did you change those yet?

    I am actually referring to One Shot usage, but the same applies for AI-Servo mode. Anytime I let the camera pick the focus point there is a perceptible lag in initial focus lock. The AF tracking modes all come into play AFTER the initial focus lock is gained. You can play with the Focus/Release priority options, but the real problem is just the decision making algorithm of the auto point selection system itself.

    These are observations from in the field use. I think every camera has it's quirks, and the 5D3 has more than it's fair share cropping up these days. Early release, bugs, who knows, I am just stoked to be using and producing with my favorite Canon ever.
  • ziggy53ziggy53 Super Moderators Posts: 23,762 moderator
    edited April 17, 2012
    The Canon 7D also has a perceptible lag in AF lock in low light, and the 7D and 5D MKIII share a very similar, if not the same, metering module. The reason that this may be significant is that both the 7D and 5D MKIII tie the metering section with the focusing section.

    The AF lag in low-light might be symptomatic to the metering module integration.

    On the 7D, the metering system can slow down the frame rate to favor AF accuracy. There is even a vague reference in the 7D User Manual. (Bottom of page 93.)

    "In low-light areas or indoors, the continuous shooting speed may become slower even if a fast shuttter speed is set"

    Is there a similar mention in the 5D MKIII owners manual? (Like maybe page number 361?)

    In low light I highly recommend the use of a flash with an AF Assist light, or at least an ST-E2. (The ST-E3-RT does not appear to have an AF Assist light.)
    ziggy53
    Moderator of the Cameras and Accessories forums
  • jmphotocraftjmphotocraft Registered Users Posts: 2,987 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    Studio shot it's 2nd wedding with the 5D mk3, and for a second time the lead shooter decided there was a SIGNIFICANT issue with "focus confirmation hesitance". In fact this lead shooter even switched back to the mk2 for a little while just to be sure they weren't just imagining the difference.

    Were they shooting with all focus points active? Letting the camera decide where to focus? If so, that's more Artificial Intelligence that you have to wait for. This was a known characteristic with the 1D line as well. Shooting action in "Ring of Fire" mode was not advised.
    -Jack

    An "accurate" reproduction of a scene and a good photograph are often two different things.
  • Matthew SavilleMatthew Saville Registered Users, Retired Mod Posts: 3,352 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    Were they shooting with all focus points active? Letting the camera decide where to focus? If so, that's more Artificial Intelligence that you have to wait for. This was a known characteristic with the 1D line as well. Shooting action in "Ring of Fire" mode was not advised.
    I can replicate the same issue, and here's the fix:
    • Use one of the TWO Single Point AF modes
    • Do NOT use any mode that requires the camera to select the AF point
    • Consider whether or not your comparing to situations in which the 5D2 would say "focused!", when it was really "close enough!"

    Same goes for AI-Servo usage. I have not found the AF Point tracking to be all that impressive. I get better results in AI servo mode my using one of the Single Point or "cluster" AF Point modes. But I am hard to please. The D700 AF Point tracking didn't even make my cut. The D3s or 1DMK4 are the only bodies with AF point tracking that is really snappy enough to rely on...for me. The good news is the 5D3 has the processing power for this to work well, I would expect firmware updates to help out in this regard. Better written algorithms for the AF point tracking/selection would make things more responsive.

    Yep, we're testing in One-Shot, Single / Spot AF, and all the different types of metering modes just in case that has an effect as well. Still no dice.

    I'm not sure exactly what you're talking about when you say "consider whether or not you're comparing to situations in which the 5D mk2 said "close enough", ...because that is indeed exactly how I'm testing this. The 5D mk2 locks nice and snappy, while the 5D mk3 takes it's time to confirm. Yeah, the 5D mk2 is just plain missing focus half the time in low light, HOWEVER, I'm also testing against a D700 and 24-70, which CAN nail shots every single time at the same zero-hesitation type of speeds that I'm used to. So for me, it is un-acceptable to just call it "the price you pay for greater accuracy". That is why I hope the camera is defective, and why I'm asking if any others who have both a mk2 and a mk3 can test and confirm the same issue.

    I'd agree that the D700 might not be as good at tracking as the D3s or a 1-series Canon, but I spend most of my time just tracking brides as they walk up the aisle, not cheetas or NFL wide receivers, Laughing.gif, ...and the rest of the time I'm in One-Shot / Single Focus.

    =Matt=
    My first thought is always of light.” – Galen Rowell
    My SmugMug PortfolioMy Astro-Landscape Photo BlogDgrin Weddings Forum
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    I'm not sure exactly what you're talking about when you say "consider whether or not you're comparing to situations in which the 5D mk2 said "close enough", ...because that is indeed exactly how I'm testing this. The 5D mk2 locks nice and snappy, while the 5D mk3 takes it's time to confirm. Yeah, the 5D mk2 is just plain missing focus half the time in low light, HOWEVER, I'm also testing against a D700 and 24-70, which CAN nail shots every single time at the same zero-hesitation type of speeds that I'm used to. So for me, it is un-acceptable to just call it "the price you pay for greater accuracy". That is why I hope the camera is defective, and why I'm asking if any others who have both a mk2 and a mk3 can test and confirm the same issue.
    =Matt=

    It may very well be defective. I am very happy with the AF performance when using Spot AF in single shot or AI servo mode.

    I agree, Matt. Nikon has set the bar for AF performance in DSLRs. If I set all my infatuation for the 5D3 aside, I'd say the D700 is probably still the better camera when it comes to simple, easy, dead reliable AF.

    But, we don't shoot Canon because of the AF capability. The 5D2 is probably the most popular wedding pro DSLR in history, and it's AF was/is atrocious. We shoot Canon because we love the dreamy skin tones of their FF sensors, the gorgeous bokeh of the 1.2 glass, and in my case, the ability to get OOC perfect images. No post! I love the D700, but as a compete image makin' machine, the 5D3 takes the cake handily.
  • OverfocusedOverfocused Registered Users Posts: 1,068 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    Had my first real photo outing with the MKIII! Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! iloveyou.giflustiloveyou.gif


    http://overfocused.smugmug.com/Bugs/Butterfly-Fields/22502197_FW4mVz#!i=1799865843&k=KnK8mRt

    Remember to view at X3 size :) Only 4 photos at the moment and I got at least 30 more keepers... I'm tired so will edit later.

    Love this camera. Yeah I could do this on the MKII, but the MKIII really is a whole world apart with AF selection/behavior and lower noise, even at ISO 400. The quiet shutter helps a ton, and the 8 second HDR makes workflow so smooth when you can skip the 10 minute edit session with 3rd party software! Things open up so much more with on-the-fly photographs.

    iloveyou.gif
  • NikolaiNikolai Registered Users Posts: 19,035 Major grins
    edited April 17, 2012
    Had my first real photo outing with the MKIII! Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! iloveyou.giflustiloveyou.gif


    http://overfocused.smugmug.com/Bugs/Butterfly-Fields/22502197_FW4mVz#!i=1799865843&k=KnK8mRt

    Remember to view at X3 size :) Only 4 photos at the moment and I got at least 30 more keepers... I'm tired so will edit later.

    Love this camera. Yeah I could do this on the MKII, but the MKIII really is a whole world apart with AF selection/behavior and lower noise, even at ISO 400. The quiet shutter helps a ton, and the 8 second HDR makes workflow so smooth when you can skip the 10 minute edit session with 3rd party software! Things open up so much more with on-the-fly photographs.

    iloveyou.gif

    Congrats! clap.gifclapclap.gif
    "May the f/stop be with you!"
  • adbsgicomadbsgicom Registered Users Posts: 3,615 Major grins
    edited April 18, 2012
    Nice stuff, Bruce. That last on the the bee is amazingly detailed.
    - Andrew

    Who is wise? He who learns from everyone.
    My SmugMug Site
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 19, 2012
    The dynamic range of the 5D3 sensor continues to impress me. Here's another sunset shot of the Cook Inlet in Anchorage, Alaska. Shot with the 24-70, S1 JPEG. This is out of camera, y'all.

    i-8NrCWQd-L.jpg

    Notice the rainbow on the left side of the image? :)
  • jmphotocraftjmphotocraft Registered Users Posts: 2,987 Major grins
    edited April 19, 2012
    Notice the rainbow on the left side of the image? :)

    WHAT DOES IT MEAN??

    :D

    Great shot. Standard picture style? Have you played around with the Landscape picture style? It also boosts blue sky.

    Any reason you're shooting in S1 other than to conserve memory cards?
    -Jack

    An "accurate" reproduction of a scene and a good photograph are often two different things.
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 19, 2012
    WHAT DOES IT MEAN??

    :D

    Great shot. Standard picture style? Have you played around with the Landscape picture style? It also boosts blue sky.

    Any reason you're shooting in S1 other than to conserve memory cards?

    Emerald picture style. I am a huge fan of this profile right now. I am shooting S1 JPEG's because they are perfect for everything I need from my snapshots. Web sharing, prints up to 16x20. For serious work, I shoot RAW, but I am finding that I create more and share more by shooting nice looking in-camera JPEGs. No editing, converting or resizing, just drag and drop to share.
  • OverfocusedOverfocused Registered Users Posts: 1,068 Major grins
    edited April 19, 2012
    http://www.twolightfilms.com/canon-5d-mkiii-high-iso-sample-footage/

    :jawdrop

    Look at those alley scenes, straight off the card!! iloveyou.gif

    The video is absolutely stellar, and I don't even do video! It is really inspiring. Just from an objective point of view, for video, this makes the D800 look like garbage. Make sure you watch it in HD and its like, nothing is missed. Flying birds, text on shadowed concrete, even the flecks of minerals in it. Just wow.
  • bloomphotogbloomphotog Registered Users Posts: 582 Major grins
    edited April 27, 2012
    Here's a sample of the interviews I took while out in Nondalton, Alaska. The original post in this thread featured some of the stills from this trip.

    This was my first video shoot with the 5D3. Monopod, with 70-200 II. Shotgun mic on boom pole into Zoom H4N.

    <!-- This version of the embed code is no longer supported. Learn more: https://vimeo.com/help/faq/embedding --> <object width="800" height="450"><param name="allowfullscreen" value="true" /><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always" /><param name="movie" value="http://vimeo.com/moogaloop.swf?clip_id=41117285&force_embed=1&server=vimeo.com&show_title=1&show_byline=1&show_portrait=1&color=00adef&fullscreen=1&autoplay=0&loop=0&quot; /><embed src="http://vimeo.com/moogaloop.swf?clip_id=41117285&force_embed=1&server=vimeo.com&show_title=1&show_byline=1&show_portrait=1&color=00adef&fullscreen=1&autoplay=0&loop=0&quot; type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" allowscriptaccess="always" width="800" height="450"></embed></object>

    Filmed on location in the remote village of Nondalton, Alaska. These video interviews are part of a growing body of work that I am contributing to the book project: "Where Water is Gold: Bristol Bay and the Pebble Mine" by Carl Johnson.
    Visit the Facebook page for this project here: facebook.com/BristolBayPebble
  • Matthew SavilleMatthew Saville Registered Users, Retired Mod Posts: 3,352 Major grins
    edited April 27, 2012
    ...Still waiting for someone to confirm or deny that in a side-by-side comparison, their mk3 hesitates to confirm focus in low light, One-Shot, Spot / Point AF, compared to the mk2... ANYBODY?????

    =Matt=
    My first thought is always of light.” – Galen Rowell
    My SmugMug PortfolioMy Astro-Landscape Photo BlogDgrin Weddings Forum
Sign In or Register to comment.