which laptop should I buy?

Comments

• Options

  ziggy53 Super Moderators Posts: 23,809 moderator

  February 18, 2013 edited February 18, 2013

  You shouldn't buy either until you decide how you will use the machine. (Or maybe you have decided how you'll use the machine but just haven't shared that information with us.)
  
  Please be as explicit as possible as to use, cameras that you wish to use and software you intend to use, quantity of images and length of video, transitions and effects that you'll use often, ... that sort of thing.

  ziggy53
  Moderator of the Cameras and Accessories forums

  0
• Options

  Bob Story Registered Users Posts: 9 Beginner grinner

  February 19, 2013 edited February 19, 2013

  laptops
  I shoot with Nikon D300s. I shoot events where I have to rename and resize JPGs quickly, I also shoot weddings and portraits raw. For programs I use, Express digital, Lightroom, Photoshop, Pro showProducer, Faststone, and do albums in FotoFusion. I only do stills. I use a external monitor at home but print with dyesubs at some events so I would like a good screen. I back up to two different hard drives so I keep under 40 gigs on the computer HD. I shoot about 1T a year. I am a little concerned about the small HD but was hoping to hook up a USB3 portable through the expresss port.
  I hope this is the info you need.
  Bob

  0
• Options

  ziggy53 Super Moderators Posts: 23,809 moderator

  February 19, 2013 edited February 19, 2013

  The Nikon D300/D300s cameras produce reasonable file sizes. Thank goodness you don't use a pair of D800 bodies.
  
  I have never used Express Digital so I can't comment on system resources or system speeds using that software. My primary concern would be Lightroom 4, if that's what you have. We have several users who commented that Lightroom 4 requires a lot more processing than LR 3 required to get the same throughput.
  
  http://www.dgrin.com/showthread.php?t=216770
  
  I suspect that either machine would be fine for a JPG only processing, but RAW files processing may seem sluggish on both machines, especially in large quantity of files.
  
  As a rule, RAM is more valuable than processor speed, and more hard drive space is almost always a benefit. It's still important to have "enough" processor speed, and whether either of these computers is fast enough for when you're shooting against a tight deadline (like customers waiting) is a tough call. I would rather suggest a third-generation, quad-core i7, with at least 2.3GHz and 12-16GB of RAM.
  
  For your work I would be afraid to work on a single SSD and single computer. If you have a contractual commitment to produce then I highly recommend redundancy. In this case I strongly suggest a backup computer and a couple of external hard drives to hold copies of the original files (unless you retain all of the original files on cards until you have verified backups elsewhere.)
  
  15" display is the absolute minimum, but a 17" display is so much nicer if you can.
  
  Finally, don't forget about the video display section. With many software supporting GPU acceleration, adding a compatible video card with lots of processing cores can give the overall throughput a major boost. The bigger cards can really suck down the batteries, so it's often a balance between speed and power utilization.
  
  If you decide that 8GB RAM is sufficient, then for $60 more you could look at a:
  
  Dell Inspiron 17R Special Edition laptop
  

  • Microsoft Windows 8 64-bit pre-installed
  • 6-cell lithium-ion battery
  • Intel Core i7-3630QM 2.4 GHz 3rd generation quad-core processor with Hyper-Threading Technology
  • 6 MB Intel Smart cache, 5 GT/s DMI speed
  • Intel HM77 Chipset
  • 8 GB DDR3 SDRAM (maximum)
  • 32 GB mSATA SSD
  • 1 TB hard drive
  • DVD±RW drive
  • NVIDIA GeForce GT 650M (2 GB)
  • IDT High Definition Audio CODEC
  • 2 stereo speakers and 1 subwoofer; Waves MaxxAudio 3
  • Integrated 10/100 Ethernet LAN
  • Integrated Intel Centrino Wireless-N 2230 802.11b/g/n + Bluetooth 4.0
  • Built-in multi-in-1 card reader

  ziggy53
  Moderator of the Cameras and Accessories forums

  0