challenge 24

nadi · October 21, 2004

A couple of potentials I took yesterday.....

cmr164 · October 21, 2004

nadi wrote:

A couple of potentials I took yesterday.....

Nice pictures both. Even though I myself eschew doing this kind of thing in PS... I thenk the top one could benefit from more striking light and the bottom from being softer perhaps even misty. YMMV

RocketMan · October 21, 2004

I like the first one in the way the color of the sky is accented in slightly blueish tint of the building. The second one is nice but maybe it could be a bit wider, somehow it doesn't say "land-scape" to me more of a detail shot and the roof of the gazebo and sky behind it is a bit bright which detracts some from the softness of the rest of the composition.

RM

miketaylor01 · October 22, 2004

I like the cityscape the best. I love the composition of the skyline and the building you chose for this, but I think the trees below make the picture feel busy. Just my opinion, but I would probably try to find a way to crop these out. Not sure if this would be possible without taking some of the bottoms of the buildings off as well though. Still a very good photo though. Keep em coming.

DJ-S1 · October 22, 2004

I really like the first one, and I like the trees at the bottom. I think that they make for a nice foreground with the curvy roof on the bottom right. I might consider cloning out the crane as it is the only non-building thing in the skyline.

Nice job!

happysnapper · October 22, 2004

I really like the city scape... Perth is a beautiful city, and youve captured that.

I love the subtle colours in the sky.

nadi · October 22, 2004

happysnapper wrote:

I really like the city scape... Perth is a beautiful city, and youve captured that.

I love the subtle colours in the sky.

thanks hapysnapper, if I entered it I was thinking of calling it "Perth: Prettier than Adelaide".....:D

.... not sure how that would be interpretted by the judges tho...

Actually, I have a strong dislike for cityscapes in general, but I thought this one was not too bad because the colours are fairly cool (as opposed to the warm yellow light in most photos I've seen of Perth). I'm a country girl at heart, and maybe thats why I have so much trouble finding a landscape around here.....?

happysnapper · October 22, 2004

nadi wrote:

thanks hapysnapper, if I entered it I was thinking of calling it "Perth: Prettier than Adelaide".....:D

Thats actually funny!!! (not tru, but funny all the same)...

I was wondering from your cityscape... do you work for Westpac or ANZ??? or are you on commission???
Its amazing how the banks logos are the only visable ones !!
Did you take them out in P/S

nadi · October 24, 2004

Nooo happysnapper I don't work for a bank..... thanks for pointing that out tho... I shall get onto it.

meanwhile, a couple more I managed this weekend....

happysnapper · October 24, 2004

I really like these 2 new shots.... I like the vineyard shot (I took one very similar yesterday), but I would like to see it in colour...

Yvette

nadi · October 24, 2004

I like the other one better.....

miketaylor01 · October 24, 2004

I like the color vineyard the best of your so far. I think it needs a tiny bit of rotation and cropping to the right though. The horizon seems a bit out of whack. Good shot though.

happysnapper · October 25, 2004

I think I like the B&W better than the colour too... can you darken the photo a bit, to bring out the features a bit more??
I think the B&W gives it an older look. Nice

lynnma · October 25, 2004

nadi wrote:

Nooo happysnapper I don't work for a bank..... thanks for pointing that out tho... I shall get onto it.

meanwhile, a couple more I managed this weekend....

Niadi I like the vineyard shot as well... I like the city scape too but we don't see too many vinyard shots here and it's very interesting.. I too would like to see it in color.
Lynn

digismile · October 25, 2004

I like the colour one the best. Hard to tell if the sun is directly overhead or directly in line with the rows of the vineyard. A shot just a sunup or sundown might give a different colour and feel to this shot.

Brad

nadi wrote:

ginger_55 · October 25, 2004

nadi wrote:

Nooo happysnapper I don't work for a bank..... thanks for pointing that out tho... I shall get onto it.

meanwhile, a couple more I managed this weekend....

Oh, my, you did well this weekend. I do like the city scape, but I love the ones from this weekend.

How will you choose?

ginger

ginger_55 · October 25, 2004

happysnapper wrote:

I really like these 2 new shots.... I like the vineyard shot (I took one very similar yesterday), but I would like to see it in colour...

Yvette

I like the vineyard in sepia, maybe the only person who does, but I do.

Also the other one, the one with all those gorgeous flowers in the foreground. I have been wanting one of those shots................ I love yours.

Put up the one everyone else likes, hehe. Supposedly we are supposed to like our photos, with our discerning eyes, so well that winning is not an issue.

I have not decided on that, I think it depends on the statement and the degree of involvement I have with certain photos.

I do love those shots. (The cityscape is good, but as Lynn said, some of us don't have vineyards in our backyards, nor do we/I know where to find one. We do grow tea here, or something, maybe I should explore that sometime.)

g

challenge 24

Comments