Question about replacing photos in smugmug and retaining comments

Oakley · July 6, 2006

- I have a photo in my smugmug site which I have posted on dgrin's whipping post for comment/critique

- On my smugmug site this photo has a comment on it and has been ranked

- I will make changes to this photo (on my computer) based on the comments/critiques in the whipping post

- Obviously, I would like the new and improved photo to replace the old one and I would use smugmug's "replace photo" funtion

- Now I haven't tested this out yet, but will I loose the comment attached to the original photo in my smugmug gallery if I do the "replace photo" funtion?

Thanks,

ivar · July 6, 2006

Oakley wrote:

...Now I haven't tested this out yet...

I just did, and all the comments are still there. Allthough not sure, i can imagine the photorank will still remain the same too.

bwg · July 6, 2006

ivar wrote:

I just did, and all the comments are still there. Allthough not sure, i can imagine the photorank will still remain the same too.

photorank will be reset

ivar · July 6, 2006

I need to learn how to read.....

Oakley · July 6, 2006

ivar wrote:

I need to learn how to read.....

Me too.....thanks guys.....

Question about replacing photos in smugmug and retaining comments

Comments