Which one is better?

Yuri Pautov

Dear friends!
Interesting to know your opinion:
1)

or

2) less colored and some PP done.



Thank you in advance,
Yuri

I, myself, think that less colored is better...

evoryware

#1 looks like you were fighting with a blue cast in her hair, her skin, the wall, and the "bags" of her eyes.
I'd like #2 more if you could put the color back into the eyes and red back into the dress.

jpl

I agree with evoryware about the blue cast in the hair and there appears slight green cast on the right upper side of her face. Having that said, I still like #1 better. Even with the color casts it looks more natural than #2 to me.

jeffreaux2

I prefer the first.

The desaturation doesn't do her any favors in the second shot.

MrBook2

I like #1 better, but I am still running an older copy of firefox, so I am not seeing them color calibrated.

Have you considered black and white for this picture?

--Aaron

dogwood

I like the second photo-- but I'd leave her skin soft like in the first photo.

Awais Yaqub

i like the 2nd most it just look too good with that background.

ShepsMom

#1 for me, beautiful girl

Travis

#1 Yuri. IMO

ladytx

#1 for me, I think because of her eyes.

GJMPhoto

Take them both!
Why not desaturate the wall only? Leave her skin tone from #1. I think the desaturation works well to subdue that chip in the wall that steals my eye from hers.

- Gary.