Need opinions .

WildWally

On which shot works better ..
#1


#2

raptorcaptor

I like the second better, but I would do a tighter crop with just the head and shoulders.

WildWally

O-K , I'll ad a third 1 !!!!!
#3

raptorcaptor

Perfect!

nrmdisk

I prefer....
I prefer number 1; the colors look more natural to me. I find the second one appears to be a bit washed out around the head and fish area, and the body seems blown. The first one retains the sahdow and body detail much better.

This is, of course, just my opinion!

N

evil eggplant

#2 works better for me. A bit less contrasty. Very nicely done, BTW.

Cheers

WildWally wrote:

On which shot works better ..
#1


#2

dbaker1221

I think I like Glenns idea on the crop best. great shot

redleash

Ditto on the cropped version--very nice!

dlplumer

WW, you keep getting better and better. I like the bird in 2 and the fish in 1.

Sp00ks

nrmdisk wrote:

I prefer number 1; the colors look more natural to me. I find the second one appears to be a bit washed out around the head and fish area, and the body seems blown. The first one retains the sahdow and body detail much better.

This is, of course, just my opinion!

N

I agree with Neil. However, #2 stands out a little better. Maybe a version in between to find that happy medium?

Jaro

I like the super cropped version. Beautiful. The other versions are nice too, but I find the water and colors a bit distracting from the action of the bird catching the fish. Great colors on the fish too.