tight or loose crop? Please vote.

rsi1986

I can't decide what one I like best. I think a vote would help.

1


2

pyry

1 Loose

Loose with these two.

However, this isn't a perfectly fair comparison, because the comp is out with the tight one. I think there's a third option here, the aproximately the top half of the first.

rsi1986

I never even considered that one. I gave it a try and love it. I may have to retake this one.

davidweaver

I like the second one. It brings to my attention that #802 is a bit taller than the rest. A good example of how cropping provides a new point of view.

rsi1986 wrote:

I never even considered that one. I gave it a try and love it. I may have to retake this one.

Ulrik_P

I guess it depends on the application of the shot. Personally I like the first one better, probably because of the weird hilly street, making it a bit more interesting. If your job is to simply shoot parking meters the second is more to the point.