Trio theme for Camera Club comp: Opinions pls.

Paul Iddon

I have more time I suppose, but my week long holiday is drawing to a close, so I wanted to get my comp entry for the club sorted.

This is my final idea, taken at the same location, again, macro lens used.


Sorry about there being 5 choices, but I had the opportunity to try different angles and poses.

Here they are:

A) "Two out of three ain't bad!"




"See you guys next week then..."




C) "I thought you two said turn left?"




D) "OK, I'll go the long way down..."




E) "Hey! Wait for me you two!"







So what do you think of these? Which would you choose?



Paul.

GOLDENORFE

hi paul, i guess i like last one best,or 1st. may be #2,but its too centred,camera club will pick up on that quickly.

last one.

phil

Paul Iddon

Thanks Phil

I doubt I'll win, but I always have a go!


Paul.

Paul Iddon

My other idea was the wheat....


Came up with these images from the wheatfield on the river bank.


Do you prefer this over idea 1?

If so, which one do think is best?

1: With texture.




2: Sepia Portrait.




3: Sepia Landscape.




4: Black and White.







Paul.

GOLDENORFE

#3 , no question.
phil

Awais Yaqub

These are very beautiful ! loved them

Paul Iddon

Thanks Awais. Much appreciated.


Paul.

Tango

i would vote for this one....

Paul Iddon

Thank you Aaron.



Paul.

Tango

ive seen you do this type of treatment a number of times, i like it so!,
i need to learn how to do it....

besides the treatment, i like the composition very much on that shot.

Tango

i like this one too.... just the bg needs some more G blur? maybe? (specifically the upper left frame)

Paul Iddon

Cheers.

On the last one above, I struggled to get the 3 heads popping out. Might try to rework it sometime.


Paul.

dwayne_bradley

Definitely #3
I have to agree with Phil. #3 without a doubt.

Dwayne

Lord Vetinari

Prefer #3 with the snails and #2 with the wheat. Not sure which is best though for an entry (I'm not good at photo judging).
Brian V.

Tango

oh ya, and ofcourse let us know what happens

Skippy

Paul Iddon wrote:

My other idea was the wheat....

Came up with these images from the wheatfield on the river bank.

Do you prefer this over idea 1?

If so, which one do think is best?

1: With texture.
2: Sepia Portrait.
3: Sepia Landscape.
4: Black and White.

Paul.

I'll vote for all of these over the snail shots
I like the #3rd shot as well .... Skippy
.

Paul Iddon

Thanks Maxine.. lol..


The path is becoming clearer...


Paul.