Some feedback needed

swintonphoto

Hey everyone - Here are a few of my attempts. Any thoughts on ones that work better?

1.


2.


3.


4.


5.


6.

JAG

I like the composition on all of them. And the 1 and 4 really stand out ...but I love 1 the most. Looks nice and clear plus love the moon! You seem to have quite a bit of haze where you live huh?

Travis

#1 by far. The colors and contrast work really well. The rest, will nice compositions, fall flat to me and don't have the pop of #1.

swintonphoto

Thanks for your input Jag & Travis. Jag, you are right - it is misty around here almost every morning. I kind of like it.

dlplumer

Travis wrote:

#1 by far. The colors and contrast work really well. The rest, will nice compositions, fall flat to me and don't have the pop of #1.

shatch

I'm a 1 and 5 vote. Great series.

quark

#5. I like the soft glow look. It is more unique than #1 compared to the other entries so far.

peterst6906

quark wrote:

#5. I like the soft glow look. It is more unique than #1 compared to the other entries so far.

I agree with this. #1 has good clarity and contrast, but I think it runs the risk of missing out in the judging because it could be difficult to distinguish it from a couple of existing entries.

Regards,

Peter

richtersl

shatch wrote:

I'm a 1 and 5 vote. Great series.

divamum

richtersl wrote:

1, 2 (which is probably as much to do with the subject as the photo - I just like it) and 5, with the nod going to #5 for me.

That said, they're all gorgeous - yet another set of images captured for this challenge to inspire me and make me want to go out and shoot some more!

eoren1

I'm going to join the minority and vote for 2. Great shot, great colors. Only wish you were allowed to clone at that really distracting line in the lower left corner...
E

Tango

Im all for #6 composition but with different light...
reshoot, get some gold in there....

#4&5 i think that parking area is a big distraction....


my .02