Autumn Colours #2- which comp best

GOLDENORFE

more shots from roddlesworth woods.
same bridge, slightly different composition,

which is best?

thanks for looking
phil
http://www.flickr.com/photos/goldenorfe/

#1


#2


#3


#4


#5


vote please
phil

edge100

#4

GOLDENORFE

edge100 wrote:

#4

thanks, thats a bit unexpected & interesting,
i much prefer the portrait framing

phil
http://www.flickr.com/photos/goldenorfe/

philipw

I'm torn between #1 and #2, but I think #1. I like the leaves in the foreground more.

Philip

Jack'll do

Definitely #2 IMO. Too much leaves in #1 detract from the main subject the bridge. In #2 the large foreground stone grabs the eye which then follows the line of stones along the bank to the bridge.

GOLDENORFE

thanks Jack & Philip, now we are getting somewhere!

phil
http://www.flickr.com/photos/goldenorfe/

Paul Iddon

I'm awkward too Phil. Number 4, lol...


Paul.

jeffmeyers

Good work on all of them. Just to add to the chaos. . . I say #1.

GOLDENORFE

thanks Paul & Jeff.
i am torn between #1 & 2 myself.
phil

redleash

Actually, I like #4 also! I like the lower vantage point because it's a bit unusual. Both 1 and 2 are superb, especially the way the water is blurred in foreground but clearer at the bridge. I just think 4 is different, so i like it.

picturegirl

Great shots!
#2 and #3 are my favs.