Help with my decision please

travelways

Hi guys,

I actually posted an image (composition) on the "Clarity and Diffuse" contest.

Here it is:



However, I'm thinking that maybe this other one is more appropriate for the theme,
since it shows both: clarity and diffuse in the same time. (This is also a composition
of my 2 photos taken at the same date):



I received good comments on both at the "photo of the day" community

Would you please help me to decide which one should I go with? :scratch

Thank you,

divamum

For me, the first one. Much more artistic, imo. While I like the idea of divided clarity/diffuse and the windscreen wiper, the wires, poles and not that photogenic view out the window weaken the idea.

travelways

Thank you so much. I see your point and it's a good one

I'll stay with the first image. Thank you again, I really appreciate your help

anonymouscuban

#1 for me too.

Tentacion

I like #2...what a nice idea and composition...I would although clone out the Pole/Wires and just leave the nice landscape...I might also add a touch of contrast, hit it with some selective color, and a play on curves.

Good Luck.
Donna P.

travelways

Thank you guys - I really appreciate your help.

Donna, yes I could play more with that landscape image...

* BTW, I like your business cards

annsan

I like the first one much better :-)
see title
ann

Kiki wrote:

Hi guys,

I actually posted an image (composition) on the "Clarity and Diffuse" contest.

Here it is:

http://allbiz.smugmug.com/photos/425832430_zLfUj-L.jpg

However, I'm thinking that maybe this other one is more appropriate for the theme,
since it shows both: clarity and diffuse in the same time. (This is also a composition
of my 2 photos taken at the same date):

http://allbiz.smugmug.com/photos/424417079_9KcWu-L-1.jpg

I received good comments on both at the "photo of the day" community

Would you please help me to decide which one should I go with?

Thank you,

travelways

Hi Ann,

Thank you for your advice

annsan wrote:

see title
ann

I did change the title

liflander

like #1
I prefer #1. It's more abstract and more interesting to me.
Nice shots!
-Mark