Which one is better?

Yuri PautovYuri Pautov Registered Users Posts: 1,918 Major grins
edited June 11, 2005 in Landscapes
Priviet, dear friends!
Can't decide which of these tow is better - color or B&W?
Each of them has their character...
Can you help me?

Color

2433.jpg

B&W
2432.jpg

Spasibo in advance,
Yuri

Comments

  • johnojohno Registered Users Posts: 617 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    You're right Yuri... Both have character... However, the color one takes me "there"... I feel the black and white one tells a story but the color one includes me in the story.

    It's a toss up... I don't think I helped the situation.

    peace.
    johno~
    If we have no peace, it is because we have forgotten that we belong to each other.
    ~Mother Teresa


    Canon 1D Mark II / Canon 50D / Canon 30D / Canon G9
    Canon 50mm 1.4
    Canon 24-105 f/4 L IS / Canon 70-200 f/2.8 L



    blog
    johno's gallery
  • NikolaiNikolai Registered Users Posts: 19,035 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    #2
    Yuri,
    second one (nice sepia!) makes it look like an old picture from the bolsheviks archives:-)
    HTH
    "May the f/stop be with you!"
  • BigAlBigAl Registered Users Posts: 2,294 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    Difficult Yuri. Both have their own character. Being me, I'd tend to go with the colored one.

    regards
    alan
    Birds
    Bugs
    Spiders
    Flowers
  • ChrisJChrisJ Registered Users Posts: 2,164 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    I prefer the color. It feels much warmer. The B&W is a bit foreboding, which is okay if that's what you want.
    Chris
  • BridgeCityBridgeCity Registered Users Posts: 338 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    Both great shots and great post processing work. I tend to lean towards the B&W simply becuase there is less to take away from the composition of the building. While the sunset (sunrise?) is beautiful, if the shot is meant to be of the wonderful angles and curves of the building, the B&W shot draws the eyes in more. The color shot says to me "been there, done that", while the B&W says "wow, look what I found!".

    Just my .02
    :dunno www.BridgeCityStudios.com:dunno
  • Tim KirkwoodTim Kirkwood Registered Users Posts: 900 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    Yuri



    Great shot! The color one does it for me. It just has that pop!~


    Tim
    www.KirkwoodPhotography.com

    Speak with sweet words, for you never know when you may have to eat them....
  • wxwaxwxwax Registered Users Posts: 15,471 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    Can't say which is better, Yuri, only which I prefer. And it's the color version. I think the pink sky adds something to the image. Whereas that same patch of sky is weaker in the B&W version. If the dark, ominous clouds extended further down, I might have preferred the B&W. Just my philistine tastes.
    Sid.
    Catapultam habeo. Nisi pecuniam omnem mihi dabis, ad caput tuum saxum immane mittam
    http://www.mcneel.com/users/jb/foghorn/ill_shut_up.au
  • ehughesehughes Registered Users Posts: 1,675 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    I'd have to vote for the color one, very nice...


    Ed
    Ed

    www.edhughesphoto.com
  • HiggmeisterHiggmeister Registered Users Posts: 909 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    Hi Yuri,
    I'm going to have to go with the color one here. The colors are nice, but it's the color contrast between the building and sky that brings out the shapes (cross, dome) more. I do like the sky better in the B&W, but overall, the color is more interesting.

    Chow,
    Chris

    A picture is but words to the eyes.
    Comments are always welcome.

    www.pbase.com/Higgmeister

  • SkippySkippy Registered Users Posts: 12,075 Major grins
    edited June 7, 2005
    Hard to Say Yuri
    Yuri Pautov wrote:
    Priviet, dear friends!
    Can't decide which of these tow is better - color or B&W?
    Each of them has their character...
    Can you help me?

    Color B&W Spasibo in advance, Yuri

    Color looks good, but the tonings in the B&W make the image take on a different look, I like the effects more on the B&W image, but I like the color one too :D hmmmmm okay if I have to choose one I'm going with B&W :D

    Skippy (Australia)
    .
    Skippy (Australia) - Moderator of "HOLY MACRO" and "OTHER COOL SHOTS"

    ALBUM http://ozzieskip.smugmug.com/

    :skippy Everyone has the right to be stupid, but some people just abuse the privilege :dgrin
  • Yuri PautovYuri Pautov Registered Users Posts: 1,918 Major grins
    edited June 9, 2005
    Spasibo all of you
    Dear friends for your comments and critique!
    Yuri
  • rahmonsterrahmonster Registered Users Posts: 1,376 Major grins
    edited June 9, 2005
    Skippy wrote:
    Color looks good, but the tonings in the B&W make the image take on a different look, I like the effects more on the B&W image, but I like the color one too :D hmmmmm okay if I have to choose one I'm going with B&W :D

    Skippy (Australia)
    15524779-Ti.gifThe colour looks warm, but the B&W looks colder and has a different feel, and more detail I think. But I still think both are very good. I think it will depend what mood you are wanting to set.
    www.tmitchell.smugmug.com

    Art washes away from the soul the dust of everyday life...Picasso
  • ian408ian408 Administrators Posts: 21,949 moderator
    edited June 9, 2005
    I prefer the first to the second. I think the color provides a greater contrast
    between the components of the image.

    Ian
    Moderator Journeys/Sports/Big Picture :: Need some help with dgrin?
  • Rufio220Rufio220 Registered Users Posts: 190 Major grins
    edited June 11, 2005
    I love that shot. I think it depends on your focus. if you want the clouds color and the beautiful sky then color. But the BW really shows the building and it's sort of rustic (i don't know if thats the right word) and nice shape.

    Either way i love it, nice shot.
    ~Take it while it's there, cause tomorrow it will be gone~
  • KhaosKhaos Registered Users Posts: 2,435 Major grins
    edited June 11, 2005
    While they're the same photo, they are different in mood.

    The first is serene, the second foreboding.

    It's really down to what mood you want to express. Both are excellent and I don't feel either outdoes the other.
Sign In or Register to comment.