DSS #34 - Last minute help please

AndMan

Ok so this challenge had me stumped.
I have had only one idea that remotely worked so if I can have your thoughts on whether any of these are worth entering:

Water - out of the bottle

#1



#2



#3



Many Thanks

Peter

Tango

im outta time, but nice concept!!

#2 is my fav comp

AndMan

Aaron,

Thanks for the quick feedback.
Much appreciated.

Peter

angevin1

I think it's perfectly doable concept...just work on the delivery of the concept as a whole and then the processing of your B&W too.

lizzard_nyc

For the challenge I say #3.
Little muddy though--maybe add contrast.

WhatSheSaw

I'm with Liz. I like the angle in #3.

adbsgicom

Would the image work more strongly with the frozen water next to an empty bottle of the same size/shape?

I like the angle on 3, through the little flip of the tablecloth on the left is a little distracting from the clean lines of the image.

Clever idea on the theme.

AndMan

Thanks for the feedback everyone, it is much appreciated.

Peter