Need An Opinion

CyberSteak

Ok I currently do any macro work with a Canon 500D diopter attatched to various lenses (28-135, 70-300, 10-22). But I've been really tempted to get a dedicated macro lens. Specifically Canon's 100mm macro. So saying that, is there any point in keeping the 500D if I buy a dedicated lens? Still fairly new to photography so I don't have a complete understanding of the 500D's bennefits and limitations. If it's redundant to have it with a dedicated lens, I'll just sell it and make the macro lens far more affordable.

Input appreciated.

craig_d

I've never used a macro attachment like yours, but it's pretty compact compared to a lens, isn't it? If so, then since you already have one, I think you should keep it in your camera bag for those occasions when you may not have your macro lens with you. It will give you a degree of macro capability at all times, even if not up to the quality level of a dedicated macro lens.

mehampson

I've heard people say good things about the bokeh using the 500D on the 100mm macro. And you might find there are shots you can get using it on one of your wider lenses that the 100mm won't give you.

My suggestion would be to wait a little while after getting the 100mm to decide, and see what place the 500D has in your kit once you're comfortable with it. Then figure out how much you'd get for selling the 500D and ask yourself if you'd spend that much to get that extra macro capability on top of the 100mm.

Lord Vetinari

In terms of magnification the 500D will not add much to a 100mm macro lens - think it will increase the max mag to 1.2 :1. Many people do use them on longer lenses for dragonfly/butterfly shooting.
Brian V.

GOLDENORFE

i have tryed the 500 on my 100mm + full set ex tubes and it only increased magnification by a tiny little bit, think it worked out about half a millimeter width wise in frame at full mag.
so not much good at increasing mag in conjunction with a macro lens really
phil

Capularis

I would say keep it for those days you need to travel light. It gives a nice boost to the close-up ability of your zoom lens without taking up too much space or adding extra weight.

CyberSteak

Thanks for all the input guys. Yeah I think I'll hold off selling the 500D and just save a little longer for the 100mm. I'm not too good at being patient.