Options

All of most recent keyword tools updated info... where is it?

WinsomeWorksWinsomeWorks Registered Users Posts: 1,935 Major grins
edited December 23, 2009 in SmugMug Support
Question #1. I haven't been on the forums as regularly lately, and have done some combing around to try to catch up on what I've missed as far as bug fixes, updates, new tools, etc. But it's pretty tricky trying to find out what all the latest keywording methodology is. I've added some photos & tried some keywording, but it's not been very evident to me what is working and what is not. I'm quite confused about present keywording as it pertains to: numbers, symbols in other languages, commas, quotation marks, hyphens, phrases containing 2 or more words, etc. etc. WHERE can I go to find all the current keywording methods, updated, in one place?? Please tell me there's such a place-- I hope & pray. Thank you.

Question #2. I would like to hear that there is an understanding that there are many folks here who are going to want to keep some of their former numerical keywords and that just because many folks were unhappy with automatic file-name & number-generated keywords, does not mean that they never want a numerical keyword again, or that they don't want to keep some of their numerical keywords from old files!! So far, I'm not hearing this understanding expressed. So my question is-- IS there this understanding by SmugMug Admins? If so, is there someplace I can see these concerns being addressed and learn how we should handle the mess we have with old file numbers present in our keywords? It's not an emergency or rush, but I'd like to know where we're at with this.

I really do not want someone else to clean it up for me, because they will have no idea which numerical keywords I want to keep & which I don't. I have years I want to keep, but not just yrs.... other numbers too. Mostly I do not want to keep old straight-from-camera file numbers. It seems we need the capability of removing old filename-generated keywords without removing years, etc. and without getting rid of our present numerical keywords that are desirable. We need ways of getting rid of this kind of thing on our own since some of it is useful while lots of it is not. If every person who keywords on here has such stuff as follows, admins can't be having to fix it all individually:
0001001004005000500100012001301501700180023002700290036005bs018019020020sbs022023023sbs025025sbs027028030030cbs033039040042045047048050f055059060060p064065070070mbs070s071073075075pbs0760770780790800810820850860900920950960970990279028502900067002300670024006700250067002600670027099tp101csc101csf102csl103css11a12a130css141cpc142cpl143cps151cpf1621p1624nd1644sb1648sb1800s1849tv1860tv1872tv1930's1930s1933 auburn1936 cord1940's1940s1950's1950s1954sb1960's1960s1970s19th century1d1drgl1d1drw1d2drgl1d2drw1dr2006 child2009 family201hbsc202hbsl203hbss20p20th century2148tv2149tv2160tv2172tv225433tv2254tv2272tv22rd241hbpc242hbpl243hbps2442lft26p26rd2dd2door2dr2dsb301csmc3038gls3048lft3054pndsk3148cp3148pn320cpmc32p350csmf360cpmf3door3dr3dsb3ths3tms40l410basmc42rd440bapmc460basmf470bapmf4742str480dmc485dmf4door4ths4tms501hsr540hpr550hstr57 chevy601sslr620splr640sssr6drw2710basg712baso720bapg722bapo760basr760p

Oh, and that's just the numbers at the beginning of my keyword list. There's another similar batch at the end of it!
Anna Lisa Yoder's Images - http://winsomeworks.com ... Handmade Photo Notecards: http://winsomeworks.etsy.com ... Framed/Matted work: http://anna-lisa-yoder.artistwebsites.com/galleries.html ... Scribbles: http://winsomeworks.blogspot.com
DayBreak, my Folk Music Group (some free mp3s!) http://daybreakfolk.com

Comments

  • Options
    AllenAllen Registered Users Posts: 10,012 Major grins
    edited December 19, 2009
    ...
    Log out and look at your list, that's what the public will see.

    I just found a bunch more when logged in and removed them one at a time. I
    cleaned all the number KW's out recently and now some show again. All these
    photos were uploaded years ago, so why are the No. KW's coming back.
    Al - Just a volunteer here having fun
    My Website index | My Blog
  • Options
    WinsomeWorksWinsomeWorks Registered Users Posts: 1,935 Major grins
    edited December 20, 2009
    Allen wrote:
    Log out and look at your list, that's what the public will see.

    I just found a bunch more when logged in and removed them one at a time. I
    cleaned all the number KW's out recently and now some show again. All these
    photos were uploaded years ago, so why are the No. KW's coming back.
    You're right, Allen-- lots fewer keywords when logged in. However, I'm just as likely to be wanting to use these numerical keywords as anyone else, so I'd still like a workable way myself to remove the unintentional ones and NOT remove the intentional ones. Id like to be able to spot numerical keywords without wading through a ton of unwanted ones.
    Anna Lisa Yoder's Images - http://winsomeworks.com ... Handmade Photo Notecards: http://winsomeworks.etsy.com ... Framed/Matted work: http://anna-lisa-yoder.artistwebsites.com/galleries.html ... Scribbles: http://winsomeworks.blogspot.com
    DayBreak, my Folk Music Group (some free mp3s!) http://daybreakfolk.com
  • Options
    WinsomeWorksWinsomeWorks Registered Users Posts: 1,935 Major grins
    edited December 22, 2009
    Latest keyword info.
    Question #1. I haven't been on the forums as regularly lately, and have done some combing around to try to catch up on what I've missed as far as bug fixes, updates, new tools, etc. But it's pretty tricky trying to find out what all the latest keywording methodology is. I've added some photos & tried some keywording, but it's not been very evident to me what is working and what is not. I'm quite confused about present keywording as it pertains to: numbers, symbols in other languages, commas, quotation marks, hyphens, phrases containing 2 or more words, etc. etc. WHERE can I go to find all the current keywording methods, updated, in one place?? Please tell me there's such a place-- I hope & pray. Thank you.

    Question #2. I would like to hear that there is an understanding that there are many folks here who are going to want to keep some of their former numerical keywords and that just because many folks were unhappy with automatic file-name & number-generated keywords, does not mean that they never want a numerical keyword again, or that they don't want to keep some of their numerical keywords from old files!! So far, I'm not hearing this understanding expressed. So my question is-- IS there this understanding by SmugMug Admins? If so, is there someplace I can see these concerns being addressed and learn how we should handle the mess we have with old file numbers present in our keywords? It's not an emergency or rush, but I'd like to know where we're at with this.

    I really do not want someone else to clean it up for me, because they will have no idea which numerical keywords I want to keep & which I don't. I have years I want to keep, but not just yrs.... other numbers too. Mostly I do not want to keep old straight-from-camera file numbers. It seems we need the capability of removing old filename-generated keywords without removing years, etc. and without getting rid of our present numerical keywords that are desirable. We need ways of getting rid of this kind of thing on our own since some of it is useful while lots of it is not. If every person who keywords on here has such stuff as follows, admins can't be having to fix it all individually:
    0001001004005000500100012001301501700180023002700290036005bs018019020020sbs022023023sbs025025sbs027028030030cbs033039040042045047048050f055059060060p064065070070mbs070s071073075075pbs0760770780790800810820850860900920950960970990279028502900067002300670024006700250067002600670027099tp101csc101csf102csl103css11a12a130css141cpc142cpl143cps151cpf1621p1624nd1644sb1648sb1800s1849tv1860tv1872tv1930's1930s1933 auburn1936 cord1940's1940s1950's1950s1954sb1960's1960s1970s19th century1d1drgl1d1drw1d2drgl1d2drw1dr2006 child2009 family201hbsc202hbsl203hbss20p20th century2148tv2149tv2160tv2172tv225433tv2254tv2272tv22rd241hbpc242hbpl243hbps2442lft26p26rd2dd2door2dr2dsb301csmc3038gls3048lft3054pndsk3148cp3148pn320cpmc32p350csmf360cpmf3door3dr3dsb3ths3tms40l410basmc42rd440bapmc460basmf470bapmf4742str480dmc485dmf4door4ths4tms501hsr540hpr550hstr57 chevy601sslr620splr640sssr6drw2710basg712baso720bapg722bapo760basr760p

    Oh, and that's just the numbers at the beginning of my keyword list. There's another similar batch at the end of it!
    Bump. would really like to know where to find out how to keyword now (since the fixes)
    Anna Lisa Yoder's Images - http://winsomeworks.com ... Handmade Photo Notecards: http://winsomeworks.etsy.com ... Framed/Matted work: http://anna-lisa-yoder.artistwebsites.com/galleries.html ... Scribbles: http://winsomeworks.blogspot.com
    DayBreak, my Folk Music Group (some free mp3s!) http://daybreakfolk.com
  • Options
    AndyAndy Registered Users Posts: 50,016 Major grins
    edited December 23, 2009
    Anna Lisa, we need to redo the keywords help page, it's time for a total refresh. Schmoo and I are on that.
  • Options
    schmooschmoo Registered Users Posts: 8,468 Major grins
    edited December 23, 2009
    Hi Anna Lisa,

    There is some oddness with your keywords and we really apologize about the confusion. The keyword improvements that we made recently were adjustments to make keywording more flexible to how users enter them.

    Basically:

    - We accept numbers of any length and they'll be indexed as you enter them
    - You can enclose groups of words (terms) in quotes for them to be entered as a single unit
    - 1 and 2 character English words and common words (and, of, the, etc) still are NOT indexed unless you enclose them in quotes
    - We accept non-English characters and words of any length
    - Apostrophes, periods, and underscores are valid characters.
    - Slashes and hyphens are NOT valid characters and will be stripped from the keyword
    - You can disable automatic extraction of keywords from your filenames in the Settings tab of your Control Panel
    - We still do not index keywords in the common format of DSC_1110.jpg or IMG_2373.jpg, etc

    The help page is in the process of being updated and pushed out, and we're sorry about the confusion in the meantime.

    As for your issue with all the keywords popping up from older files, I'll need to get together with our keyword sorcerer so that he can take a closer look. Since he's on the other side of the international date line and it's a holiday week, please give us a day or two to catch up and get back to you on this. Thanks!
  • Options
    pilotdavepilotdave Registered Users Posts: 785 Major grins
    edited December 23, 2009
    We still do not index keywords in the common format of DSC_1110.jpg or IMG_2373.jpg, etc

    This is why keywords from filenames should be turned off by default. You wouldn't need to block otherwise perfectly valid keywords like "web" and one I'd like to be using, "crw."

    You have a workaround for a workaround that prevents human beings from entering keywords that they might want to.

    Dave
Sign In or Register to comment.