Finally two ideas...please C&C this one

tinamarie52

I had two ideas today. This is the first one. I'll shoot the second one tomorrow.

Do any of these work? I'd love to have some CC. If you can offfer technical pointers...all the better!

thanks a bunch,

Chris

1


2


3


4

Tango

#4 sure seems to be a clear theme winner of the series

or #3

or #2

ok ok.... I like the all.....

but #4 seem to have just been blown out

ic4u

#4 would be my choice as well, but I do like the warm lighting in #3 too
For the challenge though, there's no mistaking #4

pyroPrints.com

#4 with lighting from #3 would be a clear choice for me, as is i think #3

dls

Beautiful work, and great concept. I love #1 visually, but #3 and #4 speak to me much more thematically. My only nitpicky comments otherwise are that I find the holder a little distracting, especially in #4, and am interested in seeing #3 using the same lighting from a slightly lower angle, possibly in a vertical orientation to emphasize the candle and smoke more. Again, excellent work, and spot on regarding the theme.

AndMan

#4 +1.
All very nice but #4 shouts out the theme, #3 is slightly more muted on the theme front.

Velvet-Art

Another vote for #4 thumb

Tim

KevXman

1 more for 4.

DsrtVW

pyroPrints.com wrote:

#4 with lighting from #3 would be a clear choice for me, as is i think #3

Kinkajou

pyroPrints.com wrote:

#4 with lighting from #3 would be a clear choice for me

travelways

#4 responds best to the theme, but like the others, I like the colors on #2 and #3

tinamarie52

Thanks for all the of helpful comments. I have re-taken the candle/smoke and have posted them in a new thread with my second idea.

I'd love some help in deciding.

Chris

travelways

tinamarie52 wrote:

Thanks for all the of helpful comments. I have re-taken the candle/smoke and have posted them in a new thread with my second idea.

I'd love some help in deciding.

Chris

Can you give a link to your other thread? - I don't see it...