DSS #55 Back to the challenge

Tylwydd

Back to the challenge with a few ideas... And already different executions... Hope they both say "stripes" though !

First idea :
#1


And second idea, completely different :
#2


And already another version :

#3


Can you help me to decide which one to submit ? Or maybe help me to improve one idea (or the other )

Thanks for viewing anyway !

pyroPrints.com

i think #1 is much more stripes then the other 2

dlscott56

#1 is really interesting.

WhatSheSaw

I agree that #1 is more stripes. What does it look like in color? I like the B&W, but I imagine some really rich tones in color.

I love #2 and #3, but they don't say stripes to me.

AndMan

WhatSheSaw wrote: »

I agree that #1 is more stripes. What does it look like in color? I like the B&W, but I imagine some really rich tones in color.

I love #2 and #3, but they don't say stripes to me.

Tylwydd

Thanks for looking and commenting ! I too think that the first one is more graphically saying "stripes".

Here is what it looks like in color :


This great organ of the cathedral of Verdun is well known and most of the famous musicians have played here at least once. It is really powerful (even the deaf can hear -or rather feel- it when it plays loud... )

MarkR

I prefer the color version, I think.

liflander

I prefer the B+W.

lkbart

I like the color version better - beautiful pipe organ! But, for the challenge, I think the B&W is stronger - looks more like stripes than the color version.

dlscott56

lkbart wrote: »

I like the color version better - beautiful pipe organ! But, for the challenge, I think the B&W is stronger - looks more like stripes than the color version.

I'm pretty sure I agree with this . Beautiful color photo though. Would love to see that cathedral.

JR303

lkbart wrote: »

i like the color version better - beautiful pipe organ! but, for the challenge, i think the b&w is stronger - looks more like stripes than the color version.

+1

Jenn

I like #1..

Tylwydd

Thanks a lot for the comments ! So I'll go with #1 (always keep the first idea ) with a title yet to find now !

The cathedral is really interesting indeed (as well as any more than a thousand years old building I guess).
Here are some shots of it :
[IMG]http://tylwydd.smugmug.com/Villes-et-Architecture/Verdun/Verdun-la-cathédrale/P2318652-copie/469026404_5MAjf-S.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://tylwydd.smugmug.com/Villes-et-Architecture/Verdun/Verdun-la-cathédrale/P2177685-copie/461683628_PPGF2-S.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://tylwydd.smugmug.com/Villes-et-Architecture/Verdun/Verdun-la-cathédrale/P2084578-copie/416425690_ka2mE-S.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://tylwydd.smugmug.com/Villes-et-Architecture/Verdun/Verdun-la-cathédrale/P2313897-copie/408966531_ZU6PD-S.jpg[/IMG]

AndMan

lkbart wrote: »

I like the color version better - beautiful pipe organ! But, for the challenge, I think the B&W is stronger - looks more like stripes than the color version.