DSS Challenge #99 (Norman Rockwell) Congrates lkbart!

JAG

Choose up to your Top 10, you have multiple votes! You may vote for one or more up to 10.
The gallery is here for commenting.


You have the ability to choose up to 10 of your top choices by selecting them from the poll.
The poll will remain open for 72 hours, and any previously registered member of DGrin may vote.

Warning: you will not be able to come back and add more choices after you click the voting button.


There were 2 disqualifications this round :cry

jwear - incorrect title format
CAPTURED2H - incorrect title format
(this has been discussed over and over, see this link: http://www.dgrin.com/showthread.php?t=93414&page=50 see post #996 for the latest discussion)


P.S. If your observant you will see that more than 10 can be chosen. Just remember if you vote for all of them its like you didn't vote :wink *Also you
are able to see any photo in its large form by clicking on it.

Jeffro

Nicely done everyone.

Jenn

voted ... I didn't have a horse in this race this time! I had no clue how to take a photo and make it look like a Norman Rockwell.

K10D

K10d
I voted, good luck to all. Nice work everyone.

jwear

JAG wrote: »

Choose up to your Top 10, you have multiple votes! You may vote for one or more up to 10.
The gallery is here for commenting.


You have the ability to choose up to 10 of your top choices by selecting them from the poll.
The poll will remain open for 72 hours, and any previously registered member of DGrin may vote.

Warning: you will not be able to come back and add more choices after you click the voting button.


There were 2 disqualifications this round :cry

jwear - incorrect title format
CAPTURED2H - incorrect title format
(this has been discussed over and over, see this link:http://www.dgrin.com/showthread.php?t=93414&page=50 see post #996 for the latest discussion)


P.S. If your observant you will see that more than 10 can be chosen. Just remember if you vote for all of them its like you didn't vote *Also you
are able to see any photo in its large form by clicking on it.

Oh ! I am soooo sorry that I added a Extra - to my post . I do see now that some added a space on both sides some no space ?. I work 7 days a week still and reading 996 post is not in my realm . Thanks again for the heads up after I posted but Jag enough said Jag -- Again I very sorry I did not read your new rule change it does seem to be of big importances

kwickers

Voted. Loved these Rockwell's great job everyone.

Moving Pictures

Yep. Again, lack of time proved an issue. I love 100, tho. Might really give that 'un a try!

NelsonK

Great work all around!

JAG

jwear wrote: »

Oh ! I am soooo sorry that I added a Extra - to my post . I do see now that some added a space on both sides some no space ?. I work 7 days a week still and reading 996 post is not in my realm . Thanks again for the heads up after I posted but Jag enough said Jag -- Again I very sorry I did not read your new rule change it does seem to be of big importances

First you need to get your facts right. I did not make this rule. It was added back when Llwellen was the mod. That was over 2 years ago. Second is that this is not the first time you have done this. It is extremely difficult for us mods to have to dq ppl, but its extremely time consuming for me to have to go through and fix all the titles especially when we have larger amounts of entries.

Post number 996 was on its own thread for over a month with a manditory must read in the title for all challenge participants. Also this rule is written in the entry gallery for about as long as its been in the rules. I cannot see how difficult it is for ppl to comply with a simple rule. Your previous infractions were changed by others. I made my warning post and last challenge was the first time I had to dq someone for it. I really do not like doing it but it was written in the rules for a reason.

Hopefully ppl will learn quickly and not repeat the mistake. As for spaces between the dashes, that is not important. Having dgrin name - title is important. I cannot make ppl come read the rules, however I will hold everyone to these rules.

You can either hate me as a meany or you can respect me for applying the same rules for everyone. Nuff said.

Azgard

Well done folks. These look great!

ghinson

JAG wrote: »

First you need to get your facts right. I did not make this rule...Having dgrin name - title is important. I cannot make ppl come read the rules....

Why is this rule important again? Might help if we understand why the titling matters. We certainly don't want to chase anyone away for what many might think is a trivial thing.

Troy Raymond

Having held contests myself I understand the rules. They consume a large amount of time to run, rules help reduce the time spent. New members entering will have their ID's confirmed with a copy and paste for a search, if spelled incorrectly it does not warrant a search for the correct name by the person for actual prize notification if placing a top 5.

The reason this was written in as a rule and not a suggestion is that we need it to be this format in order to copy and paste it. It does not say to use a ~ or -- or : or ; or ... for a reason.

Now imagine if 30 percent of the people did not follow the formatting rules, the person running the show will then need to correct each by hand consuming even more time.

Lets not forget they also have to end the current challenge, start a new challenge, check all EXIF of each entry and photos used, plus user names... then create a link to each image and copy/paste the "name - title" for the voting poll thread.... then update the "The DGRIN SHARP SHOOTERS (DSS) Challenges (Quick links to all things official) README" thread, and the archives... 80+ participants can really take some time!

Then.... notify all the winners and prepare their names for acceptance into the mega challenge! (which requires twice the work during a mega)

One thing I did notice is the "Winners Gallery" has not been updated in quite some time... I'm not sure why is stopped, but no one should receive flack for it anyway.

If a single person has to correct all the entries to make sure they are eligible, the amount of time needed will start to result in regret for taking on the task (while also running their own business), only to regret having to find someone else to keep them going or let them end.

There is a lot that goes on behind the scenes to keep challenges running.

Troy

JAG

ghinson wrote: »

Why is this rule important again? Might help if we understand why the titling matters. We certainly don't want to chase anyone away for what many might think is a trivial thing.

Find the explination in this post...
http://www.dgrin.com/showpost.php?p=1730104&postcount=996

No sense in me beating a dead horse, this was discussed at length when it first was written into the rules. And has been brought up a couple of times as a reminder. I just am not going to spend the time fixing it for all those who choose to ignor what is written in the rule anymore. Any other competition I have entered that was not dgrin, there was always rules that specifically said how you were to enter with names and such. They wanted a certain format. I do not see why this is so difficult for some but hopefully they are quick learners.

JAG

Thanks Troy for your understanding and explination. We must have been writing our responses about the same time. I appreciate your answer. I really do not like to dq ppl. But this is a little rediculous that when we do all we can do to keep ppl informed, short of pm'ing everyone (which in my experience so far even that has not helped for when I pm'ed for this infraction the round before this.) I just do not have the time to spend anymore time on this. Rules are rules and if they do not want to follow them, then they will get dq'ed.

As for the winner gallery. I am aware it is lacking quite a few. Sean got behind with his work schedule picking up, then when I took over I have yet to find the time to go back and update it completely. Maybe I will when I get back in town.

JAG

Announcing the top 5 images for DSS #99 - Norman Rockwell

CONGRATULATIONS lkbart for the #1 image win!


The following photographers are now qualified to participate in Mega Challenge #16.

lkbart
Aaron Nelson
K10D
sweetharmony
Bryce Wilson

Congrates to all the top 5 and to those who participated and commented a big thank you!
Winning PM's will be sent out ASAP

GretaPics

Congratulations lkbart for a fantastic image that fits this challenge so well. And to the other winners - you all got my vote too. Nicely done. GP

WhatSheSaw

I knew it! Congrats, Lillian for a perfect Rockwell rendition! The poses of the singer and pianist and the muted background are truly in the Rockwell style. The cat is the perfect final touch.

Congrats to the other finalists! Well done. I really enjoyed all of the entries this round.

sweetharmony

A well-deserved first place! It was super! Congrats to the other winners as well.....
Thanks for the votes and the great comments on this round.....I think quite a few of us stretched quite a bit this time, and the results were quite good.

richtersl

Well done, everyone!!! clap Congrats to the winners!

K10D

K10d
Congrat's to IKbart for tdhe winning Photo. Well deserved. Congrats to the rest of the winners & thanks to all that voted for mine. Its my first ever win & I'm thrilled. Love this site & this contest. Keeps me on my toes. Thanks Again to all & Congrats to All. Everyone who entered had great Photo's.

divamum

This was just an outstanding entry in Rockwell style. From the painterly background, to the pose, to the muted tones, to the checked shirt to the KITTEN (omg, so perfect!!) it nailed it. A clear winner IMO - there were some other really great shots in this round (kudos to all), but this one really was exceptional!

kdotaylor

Congratulations to Lillian and the other four--they were truly outstanding photos. Lillian, all the little Rockwellian details added up to a perfect entry!

Moving Pictures

[SCOOBY]
I would have had a chance if it weren't for that meddling kitten!
[/SCOOBY]</SCOOBY>

lkbart

Thanks so much - it really is exciting to win! A very cool challenge, I had lots of fun playing with this one. Congrats to the other top 5! And a special shout-out to kitty Fred who decided this shot needed to be an action shot rather than sitting posed! A print of this will make a perfect Mother's Day gift for my mother, since my 2 kids were the models!

Andy

JAG wrote: »

You can either hate me as a meany or you can respect me for applying the same rules for everyone. Nuff said.

I thank you for your tireless efforts and know that the reason behind this rule is to make it so you don't have to spend extra time dealing with reformatting and such. Thanks for all you do.

JAG

Andy wrote: »

I thank you for your tireless efforts and know that the reason behind this rule is to make it so you don't have to spend extra time dealing with reformatting and such. Thanks for all you do.

Thank you!

JAG

lkbart wrote: »

Thanks so much - it really is exciting to win! A very cool challenge, I had lots of fun playing with this one. Congrats to the other top 5! And a special shout-out to kitty Fred who decided this shot needed to be an action shot rather than sitting posed! A print of this will make a perfect Mother's Day gift for my mother, since my 2 kids were the models!

That is a wonderful gift idea!

richtersl

Andy wrote: »

I thank you for your tireless efforts and know that the reason behind this rule is to make it so you don't have to spend extra time dealing with reformatting and such. Thanks for all you do.

Ditto!

Froch

lkbart wrote: »

Thanks so much - it really is exciting to win! A very cool challenge, I had lots of fun playing with this one. Congrats to the other top 5! And a special shout-out to kitty Fred who decided this shot needed to be an action shot rather than sitting posed! A print of this will make a perfect Mother's Day gift for my mother, since my 2 kids were the models!

Nothing would be more perfect!
Congratulations! Just an outstanding entry!

SeascapeS

Congratulations winners! Fantastic entries!

billseye

Gotta say, I loved the winning photo the minute I saw it. Kudos on capturing the mood and subject to reflect a modern take on Rockwell. Love the timing of the cat coming down off the piano.

Lots of good Rockwells in the gallery, too. Fun challenge!