Help me pick a napper

david-low

These were shot in Delhi train Stn.

Spotted both of them inside the train cabin. Could be one of those that slipped in to take a nap before the train pulls away as I don't see any other passengers.

What version do you prefer.

Eldon Shea

Nice shots. I vote for C. The shallow depth of field blurs the scene outside the window, which makes it seem that the train is in motion. The colors are very nice. I prefer it to the b/w. If it was my shot, I would try to remove the sandal from A/B. For me, A/B works better as monochrome. Nice work.
Bryan

david-low

Eldon Shea wrote: »

Nice shots. I vote for C. The shallow depth of field blurs the scene outside the window, which makes it seem that the train is in motion. The colors are very nice. I prefer it to the b/w. If it was my shot, I would try to remove the sandal from A/B. For me, A/B works better as monochrome. Nice work.
Bryan

Tks Eldon

Stumblebum

B and C for me.....
B as it has more kick and b&w always adds something....
C because the glow is better and b&w is making it bit ghostish.....

travelways

I definitely like C

Juano

C is beautiful! Great expression on her face, nice light and DOF. Very nice.

david-low

Tks everyone for input. Quite the same as my opinion, i.e. B and C

CCoop

I go with D for the timeless look of b/w. And really like the light on the face, and her unawareness of the camera.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Seefutlung

C pour moi. I found the lone sandel distracting and I was very tempted by D, but the odd lighting outweighed the timelessness of B&W. In C the warm colors invite the viewer into the image, the coldness of the monochrome leaves the viewer with a stark realty.