Same Photo...2 Edits

PhotoDavid78

Here is the same photo of Indian Brook Falls in Garrison, NY with 2 different edits.
Can you please tell me which one you like better and why? Thank you!

1

2

Stumblebum

They are not close......

First one has light and warmth.....

Second one is dull

PhotoDavid78

Here is a third edit. I think I like the color and light from 1 with the crop and depth of number 2.

Stumblebum

I agree, definitely depth adds to it more, so good idea to combine the best of both......the first has bit of 2d feel that third one removes. Fantastic capture either way.

Cornflake

The photos in your first post aren't showing up for me but I like your revision a lot.

PhotoDavid78

@Cornflake said:
The photos in your first post aren't showing up for me but I like your revision a lot.

oops. I deleted them from my website so it deleted it from here.

bfluegie

I don't know what the first two looked like, but the third one rocks! The combination of the light and detail is a winner with me.