RESULTS: Mini Challenge #342: It's a Rocky World

sarasphotossarasphotos Registered Users Posts: 3,830 Major grins

This was tough to judge, as every set had at least one winning photo and because of the broad topic I had to compare a lot of apples to oranges.

@JAG love this set! Each had a good amount of "rockiness", although #3 was slightly more about the bird than the rocks. I especially liked the serenity of #1 and #2 is a beautiful portrayal of the rocky landscape.

@grandmaR my favorite of your three is the "Moll Dyer" rock. It's a great story and the picture is definitely about the rock. I enjoyed #1 as well (cobblestones) but #2 was not as strong because it was slightly out of focus.

@Cavalier another great set, each giving me a very specific sense of place as well as a textural feeling of the rocks. My favorite of the three is #1 - the moss looks like a lush green carpet. #3 brought back many memories for me of driving through the California foothills as a young adult. I loved the power of #2 - I can hear the crash of the waves as I view the picture, but I am slightly bugged by the slanting horizon.

@pegelli I found these shots very interesting and would love to know where they were taken. It's fascinating how the plates of rock stack up on one another - geology at work! My favorite of the bunch is #3 "Natural arch"

@sapphire73 on our visit to Joshua Tree, my husband and I were also very impressed by the rock piles, which you've captured very nicely here. (BTW, I hope you're feeling better!)

@slpollett wow - three impressive pictures, although all three of them had more to do with the interplay between rock and water than just "rock". The Horseshoe Bend photo is great! I can appreciate the difficulty of getting the shot, as when we were in the area we didn't even stop because both parking lots were full. In #2 I love that big fat rock in the middle that breaks up the flow of the stream.

And the winners are...

2nd Place: a tie between
@Cavalier 1) Moss covered rocks - Mariposa County, Ca.

@slpollett 2) This is from the trail to Anna Ruby Falls near Helen, Georgia

The winner is:
@JAG 1) Pile O' Rocks in Homer Alaska

Joyce, it's over to you now!


  • Options
    CavalierCavalier Registered Users Posts: 3,033 Major grins

    Loved the topic for a well-run mini, Sara. Thanks for the 2nd place tie with Sherry. And Joyce's Pile O' Rocks definitely deserves the winning nod - perfect representation of the topic and a great shot!

  • Options
    JAGJAG Super Moderators Posts: 9,088 moderator

    Thank you, Sara, for a well run mini and for the first placing as well as comments. Congrats to @slpollett and @Cavalier for the 2nd tie runner ups! I will get something up soon.

  • Options
    grandmaRgrandmaR Registered Users Posts: 1,946 Major grins

    Very well judged mini. I knew the Moll Dyer rock was very 'rocky' but not really as good a photo as the ones entered by other people. I loved Joyce's stacked rocks.

    “"..an adventure is an inconvenience rightly considered." G.K. Chesterton”
  • Options
    pegellipegelli Registered Users Posts: 8,777 Major grins

    Congrats @JAG for a great rocky image and winning the challenge, I liked it from the moment you posted it. Also congrats to @Cavalier and @slpollett for a shared second place, also wonderful images.
    Thanks for the comments and a well run mini Sara, and good picks for the winner and runner up. To answer your question, all my three submissions were taken in (on?) Newfoundland where we spent a 3 week vacation late May/early June. Wonderful nature and landscapes, extremely friendly people but still a bit on the cold side, but that didn't stop us from making lots of long hikes in the woods or along the rugged shoreline.

    Pieter, aka pegelli
    My SmugMug
Sign In or Register to comment.