Challenge 70: 3 water contrast photo.. help!

livefreenski

which photo best shows the theme do you believe

Golden Rod

the metal and water contrast
or..
Pond Scum

here the black and white is the contrast
and finally

Two types of water..

the contrast is the turbulent water and the still water

please let me know your thoughts dgrinners..

saurora

Definitely #3 for me.

livefreenski

thanks man. ne other opinions?

AfterImage

Number 3 for me too... It's the better of the three and a beautiful shot to boot!

livefreenski

thank you and that is the one i entered

livefreenski

sadly i did not make it to the final vote though