Three new choices... can you help me decide?

photogmomma

Frozen bubbles - should I PS out that rock in the lower right? Crop it out?



Swirled ice - I like it, but find the color lack luster. The photo after this is a B&W version of a similar area.


Cool swirls - Since I felt the color in the previous one was boring (even after bumping saturation), I tried it in B&W with a blue tint.


Thanks a TON for all your comments in advance!

photogmomma

Okay, FOUR photos. !
Swirled ice - slightly different crop, different treatment like last photo to bring out shapes.



Does it even seem "chilled"?

pyroPrints.com

I think I like #3 the best

photogmomma

pyroPrints.com wrote:

I think I like #3 the best

Thanks so much! (Actually, that's the one I keep leaning towards... Shh, don't tell anyone since I don't want to affect their opinions!:D )

Bendr

I concur, number 3 has the best curves!

LiquidAir

photogmomma wrote:

Thanks so much! (Actually, that's the one I keep leaning towards... Shh, don't tell anyone since I don't want to affect their opinions!:D )

No worries-- I made up my mind before I saw this. Cool Swirls (the first crop) is the winner in my eyes.

photogmomma

Thanks, all! I really appreciate the feedback. Just replaced for that photo.

Flyinggina

I'm late with my comment, but I agree that #3 is the one. It is a more pleasing photograph overall than your original entry IMHO. Good luck!!

Virginia

lynnesite

Flyinggina wrote:

I'm late with my comment, but I agree that #3 is the one. It is a more pleasing photograph overall than your original entry IMHO. Good luck!!

Virginia

I like #3 also, and the tint you chose.

photogmomma

Thanks, Virginia and Lynne! Helps me a lot that you chimed in - even if it was late. I'm feeling a little better about it.

Thanks!

LilleG

I like the contours, and the tint, of #3.

amy wilburn

2 more opinions cause I know we photogs like feedback
when I saw your new entry I thought: wow, I really like your update

and an even better compliment from my hubby: after I forced him to check out ALL the entries, when I asked "so what do you think?" without missing a beat he told me your swirled ice pic was his fave:)

photogmomma

LilleG, thanks so much! I really appreciate your feedback!

amy wilburn wrote:

when I saw your new entry I thought: wow, I really like your update

and an even better compliment from my hubby: after I forced him to check out ALL the entries, when I asked "so what do you think?" without missing a beat he told me your swirled ice pic was his fave:)

Thanks a ton, Amy! You're right - it's always wonderful to hear things like that! Thanks for posting!