I also need help, should I change entry????!

klphoto

Here is the original entry:



Should I change to one of these:

I removed the pics to clean up the folder they were in.....

Thanks in advance for opinions!

Nikolai

klphoto wrote:

Here is the original entry:
Should I change to one of these:
Thanks in advance for opinions!

I think your original one is far more original than the new ones (which are plenty good, too).

To be honest, I'm not a big fan of such a centered framing, but it still stands out.

Don't sweat it, you're good:-)

Robert

How can you even consider it? The original one is a great shot.

klphoto

Thanks for your quick responses!

I agree with you Nikolai. I am usually not keen on centered framing, but with this shot it seemed to isolate the tree and give the picture a bit more impact for me.


I will be keeping the original...thanks again.

ChrisJ

The lone tree is definitely more irregular to me than picturesque (not a bad thing!). I like the final reflection shot, but I don't think the image pops enough for me. You needed a bit more light in the foreground.

I'd stick with the original.

Swartzy

This doesn't even come close
to the original...hands down...the one you have entered is best...great shot....now, stop.