Which version do you prefer

chopskychopsky Registered Users Posts: 104 Major grins
edited May 6, 2007 in Landscapes
Hey guys,

Which version of this photo do you prefer? Uncropped or cropped (and converted to B&W)?

Thanks!
Grant

chapman__s_peak_pt__3_by_chopsky.jpg



roaduv8.jpg
Currently Using:
body: canon 400d
lenses: 50mm 1.8 & 10-22mm

Grant Shapiro Design & Photography

Comments

  • ShepsMomShepsMom Registered Users Posts: 4,319 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    Wahh, such a decission, it probably would make it easier if you post all the versions to compare! !:D
    Marina
    www.intruecolors.com
    Nikon D700 x2/D300
    Nikon 70-200 2.8/50 1.8/85 1.8/14.24 2.8
  • chopskychopsky Registered Users Posts: 104 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    ShepsMom wrote:
    Wahh, such a decission, it probably would make it easier if you post all the versions to compare! !:D

    huh? I did? maybe you didnt let it load for long enough. there's 2 of them.
    Currently Using:
    body: canon 400d
    lenses:     50mm 1.8 & 10-22mm

    Grant Shapiro Design & Photography
  • Chrissiebeez_NLChrissiebeez_NL Registered Users Posts: 1,295 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    eek7.gif i only see one.. maybe the next viewer wont see anyone at all ? rolleyes1.gif

    the photo is nice though! ;)
    Visit my website at christopherroos.smugmug.com
  • ShepsMomShepsMom Registered Users Posts: 4,319 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    chopsky wrote:
    huh? I did? maybe you didnt let it load for long enough. there's 2 of them.

    Nope, still only see one ne_nau.gif
    Marina
    www.intruecolors.com
    Nikon D700 x2/D300
    Nikon 70-200 2.8/50 1.8/85 1.8/14.24 2.8
  • ElaineElaine Registered Users Posts: 3,532 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    I see one image, and one little red x.
    That's a very interesting angle on that first one...makes me feel like I'm gonna fall off the edge of the earth! I like how the road leads you in and the sky is nice.

    Elaine
    Elaine

    Comments and constructive critique always welcome!

    Elaine Heasley Photography
  • chopskychopsky Registered Users Posts: 104 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    SORRY EVERYONE! Ok, I've changed the link. Should work now :)
    Currently Using:
    body: canon 400d
    lenses:     50mm 1.8 & 10-22mm

    Grant Shapiro Design & Photography
  • ElaineElaine Registered Users Posts: 3,532 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    I prefer the color version!

    Elaine
    Elaine

    Comments and constructive critique always welcome!

    Elaine Heasley Photography
  • Chrissiebeez_NLChrissiebeez_NL Registered Users Posts: 1,295 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    oohh hard choice.. i like the color but i also like the black bars in the b&w version.. rolleyes1.gif
    Visit my website at christopherroos.smugmug.com
  • likwidlikwid Registered Users Posts: 28 Big grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    I would like a cropped color version :D

    Very nice image either way.

    // Sebastian
    Canon EOS 30D | Sigma EX 18-50/2.8 DC
    Sony A-100 | Sony 18-70 kit lens | Tamron 70-300mm 4-5.6 | Minolta 50mm 1.7
    // Sebastian
  • ShepsMomShepsMom Registered Users Posts: 4,319 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    chopsky wrote:
    SORRY EVERYONE! Ok, I've changed the link. Should work now :)

    Thanks for fixing it. I'd prefer color one, B&W just dosn't do nothing for me ne_nau.gif But it's about you and what works for you that matters!!
    Good shots! thumb.gif
    Marina
    www.intruecolors.com
    Nikon D700 x2/D300
    Nikon 70-200 2.8/50 1.8/85 1.8/14.24 2.8
  • chopskychopsky Registered Users Posts: 104 Major grins
    edited May 6, 2007
    ShepsMom wrote:
    Thanks for fixing it. I'd prefer color one, B&W just dosn't do nothing for me ne_nau.gif But it's about you and what works for you that matters!!
    Good shots! thumb.gif

    Yeh, I understand that. And thanks for the compliment ;)
    It's just that Im quite torn between the 2. Personally, I actually prefer the composition of the 2nd (B&W) version, but I like the sky in the uncropped version.
    Currently Using:
    body: canon 400d
    lenses:     50mm 1.8 & 10-22mm

    Grant Shapiro Design & Photography
  • annnna8888annnna8888 Registered Users, Super Moderators Posts: 936 SmugMug Employee
    edited May 6, 2007
    For me, definitely the uncropped color version. The colors are just spectacular, don't throw them away! mwink.gif And cropping the sky out on top makes the composition too tight, IMHO.
    Good work!

    Ana
    Ana
    SmugMug Support Hero Manager
    My website: anapogacar.smugmug.com
Sign In or Register to comment.