Over Joyed, Narrow Me Down

indiegirl

Please help me choose! C/C welcome.

#1
Sisters


#2
Pinwheel


#3
Having a Ball

S. Horton

FWIW, little C&C

#1 I'd consider tightening the crop on that work to draw the eye in a bit; love that shot, got my vote.

But, I shoot mostly sports, we just shoot tight and crop tighter!

pyroPrints.com

#1 is an awesome shot. nice capture =c)
the other 2 are nice, but not really contenders in my eyes

saurora

Having a sister is one of my biggest joys in life, so I certainly go along with #1. Plus I like the shot alot! I also agree that a tighter crop would make it stronger.

indiegirl

How's this crop?

Greensquared

indiegirl wrote:

Really, really nice, although I'd keep more at the top personally. Great image.

S. Horton

You're doing nice work! Would you like to share how you did the B/W conversion as well? I struggle with those!

indiegirl

Shhhh...don't tell anyone, but I am probably the most untechnical photographer here. I don't know how to use Photoshop (gasp!), I use Picasa (again, gasp!) to crop and do minor color balancing on my shots--

For this one, I used the b/w converstion tool, then played with the highlights and shadows until I thought they looked good.

When I moved from film to digital SLR, I lost a lot in my technical skills and feel as if I'm starting over on a lot of levels. I am not scared of Photoshop, but it seems like such a freaking task to learn.

I'd like to move from where I am to a more technically proficent place.

pyroPrints.com

indiegirl wrote:

Shhhh...don't tell anyone, but I am probably the most untechnical photographer here. I don't know how to use Photoshop (gasp!), I use Picasa (again, gasp!) to crop and do minor color balancing on my shots--

For this one, I used the b/w converstion tool, then played with the highlights and shadows until I thought they looked good.

When I moved from film to digital SLR, I lost a lot in my technical skills and feel as if I'm starting over on a lot of levels. I am not scared of Photoshop, but it seems like such a freaking task to learn.

I'd like to move from where I am to a more technically proficent place.

There are quite a few movies showing you basic and advanced Photoshop techniques. Great way to learn PS. I can't remember any of their names but I'm sure if you just google it, you will find some. Any one else wanna jump in with some names?

richtersl

Gosh...I was going to suggest a different approach and that is to get Photoshop Elements, which is a fraction of the cost of what Photoshop is. Use Elements to teach yourself the basics and then work your way up to Photoshop.

BTW, there are some really good PS tutorials right here in Dgrin.

Flyinggina

Definately #1. What a lovely, lovely shot. To me it says intimacy more than joy and makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside but not joyous. However, from the other responses it is clear that others get the joy message loud and clear. Sometimes an entry that is overall compelling but not necessarily super strong on the theme makes it to the top. Your photograph is definitely compelling and very special among the children shots being entered. Good luck!!

Virginia

indiegirl

I do have PS Elements and plan on taking the plunge this summer. Thanks, everyone! ETA: I changed the crop in the final. Check it out!

Jesse

k2butter

indiegirl wrote:

I do have PS Elements and plan on taking the plunge this summer. Thanks, everyone! ETA: I changed the crop in the final. Check it out!

Jesse

I used picasa before I got elements, and it was not that hard of a transition... I used a lot of the auto features on elements while I figured out how everything worked... I love that first photo, it is so beautiful....

Greensquared

indiegirl wrote:

I do have PS Elements and plan on taking the plunge this summer. Thanks, everyone! ETA: I changed the crop in the final. Check it out!

Jesse

Love it.

saurora

Love the crop! Elements is very intuitive and yet a simplified version of Photoshop. It's a very powerful tool. I had to wean myself away from it when I started using Photoshop!!! I missed how easy it was! Good luck in the challenge.

indiegirl

Well, 5 "Keep Shooting" responses but no helpful critique from those voters! C'mon, gang. We're all friends, here.

Tentacion

Hiya Indie, I voted for "Sisters"

I feel that the photo expresses a sweet and innocent intimacy between sisters, that many will wish they had a sister, ....My only thing is that I wish I could see a bit more of the eye of the sister on the left, but then one could think that extends the mystery of it all.

I love the soft tendrils vs the straight hair, then I wonder what they are cooking up, that makes them have to talk so closely in such a "hush "hush" manner...

I can't really say what emotion it sparked, but I was smiling, as I looked at the photo, and it brought back many good memories!!

I really like it....

Good Luck in whichever you choose.
Donna

HoofClix

indiegirl wrote:

Well, 5 "Keep Shooting" responses but no helpful critique from those voters! C'mon, gang. We're all friends, here.

Hey Indie! Here's to coming out of the "vote-closet!"

I voted "keep shooting" simply because I don't think any of the photos you put up follow either side of the theme. #1, the best photo of them all, brings forth from me more of a touching view of sisterly love. I have two daughters, so I related immediately. I also think that the B&W conversion of that one even further masks whatever joy that it started with. But that's just me. There are six judges on this who will each have their own viewpoint and who will neither require color for joy nor B&W for sorrow.

But let me be clear.. #1 smacked me in the face as great when I saw it, and the advice on it that you've gotten already has helped improve it!

Onward!

photogmomma

Okay, okay, I'll be brave as one of the "keep shooting" people!

I LOVE LOVE LOVE this shot. Did I say "LOVE"? Seriously, it's amazing and has so much emotion. But the emotion that comes across is "LOVE" not, "JOY" to me. It's affection, caring, sweet sisterly love, but not joy. That's the only reason I say that....

(As a note, I typed this up several hours ago! And I never sent it... Ugh! Sorry... Silly kids getting in my way. )

indiegirl

THANK you Mark and Andi! I appreciate the feedback.

indiegirl

saurora wrote:

Love the crop! Elements is very intuitive and yet a simplified version of Photoshop. It's a very powerful tool. I had to wean myself away from it when I started using Photoshop!!! I missed how easy it was! Good luck in the challenge.

Thanks for the PS encouragement folks!

indiegirl

Tentacion wrote:

Hiya Indie, I voted for "Sisters"

I feel that the photo expresses a sweet and innocent intimacy between sisters, that many will wish they had a sister, ....My only thing is that I wish I could see a bit more of the eye of the sister on the left, but then one could think that extends the mystery of it all.

Yes, this was my feeling, too. I wish I could have gotten more of her hair. She was being quite wild, though. Thanks for the feedback.