Looking for some feedback

dlplumer · May 30, 2009

I'm thinking of entering this in the modified light challenge. This is an HDR I took this week while I was in the Canadian Rockies.

Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

Spring Thaw

anwmn1 · May 30, 2009

Hey Dan

First of all I am very jealous of your trip. Banff is on my top five list.

I think there is still some work you can do on this one. The sky and the mountains on the right have some blotchy spots that could be cleaned up. I think you could enhance the sky a little more too. Need to get a little depth and pop into the clouds to match the rocks detail in the foreground.

Do you have more shots similar to this?

dlplumer · May 30, 2009

anwmn1 wrote:

Hey Dan

First of all I am very jealous of your trip. Banff is on my top five list.

I think there is still some work you can do on this one. The sky and the mountains on the right have some blotchy spots that could be cleaned up. I think you could enhance the sky a little more too. Need to get a little depth and pop into the clouds to match the rocks detail in the foreground.

Do you have more shots similar to this?

Thanks Aaron. It was the best. You will love it. I finally captured a loon which is on the wildlife forum. I'll be posting shots from this trip for a while.

Appreciate your feedback. Here is one based on your feedback and a couple of others.

anwmn1 · May 30, 2009

The first one is much better now in my opinion.

That last one is really nice. I think if you can add some more clarity and contrast in the mountain and slightly lighten the trees it will be the best of all of these.

WOW- what an awesome place! Wish I could go. :cry

shniks · May 30, 2009

Hey Dan- I actually really like this picture. Great depth (one feels one is at that place).

Cheers,

shniks · May 30, 2009

This one is SPECTACULAR!

Cheers,

Tango · May 30, 2009

and the one you have planned to use for the challenge is not to shabby either...

dlplumer · May 30, 2009

anwmn1 wrote:

The first one is much better now in my opinion.

That last one is really nice. I think if you can add some more clarity and contrast in the mountain and slightly lighten the trees it will be the best of all of these.

WOW- what an awesome place! Wish I could go. :cry

dlplumer · May 30, 2009

This one is SPECTACULAR!

Cheers,[/quote]

Thanks very much Nik. I re-did this one as Aaron suggested and now I think I will enter this one.

Hikin' Mike · May 31, 2009

I like the compositions, and as an HDR, it's pretty good. The sky still has that 'gray-look' like most HDRs that I've seen. If it were me, I would blend the two together using Layer Masks.

I like your last photo, but I don't care for the two different colors (purple sky, blue reflection). It's just not natural looking to me.

NorthernFocus · May 31, 2009

That's one hell of a shot, Dan. All nice but the final one here is really something. Bringing out the trees really helped. Wonderful image

dlplumer · May 31, 2009

Hikin' Mike wrote:

I like the compositions, and as an HDR, it's pretty good. The sky still has that 'gray-look' like most HDRs that I've seen. If it were me, I would blend the two together using Layer Masks.

I like your last photo, but I don't care for the two different colors (purple sky, blue reflection). It's just not natural looking to me.

Mike, do you prefer this:

NorthernFocus · May 31, 2009

I do

Hikin' Mike · May 31, 2009

dlplumer wrote:

Mike, do you prefer this:

Better, but the bottom (reflection) should always be a tad darker than the actual image (top).

dlplumer · May 31, 2009

Hikin' Mike wrote:

Better, but the bottom (reflection) should always be a tad darker than the actual image (top).

Eia · May 31, 2009

Wow! This one!

dlplumer · May 31, 2009

Eia wrote:

Wow! This one!

Thanks Eia. I think I'll go with this one. This was quite a refreshing change from our dry desert:ivar

CWSkopec · May 31, 2009

I really like that last version, Dan!! Great work and beautiful shots!!!

Awais Yaqub · May 31, 2009

Wow last is killer !

dlplumer · May 31, 2009

CWSkopec wrote:

I really like that last version, Dan!! Great work and beautiful shots!!!

Thanks Chris. If you haven't been there, put it on your bucket list

CWSkopec · May 31, 2009

dlplumer wrote:

Thanks Chris. If you haven't been there, put it on your bucket list

Good thing I haven't hit the big 3-0 quite yet... you good folks here on DGrin have already added enough to my bucket list that I don't think I'll be allowed to finally kick "it" until I'm about 162 years old!!

Hikin' Mike · May 31, 2009

dlplumer wrote:

.

"More Better"!

Jack'll do · May 31, 2009

That last one is simply GREAT Dan.

thumb

dlplumer · May 31, 2009

Hikin' Mike wrote:

"More Better"!

Thanks Mike. I appreciate the constructive criticism. It was very very helpful

dlplumer · May 31, 2009

CWSkopec wrote:

Good thing I haven't hit the big 3-0 quite yet... you good folks here on DGrin have already added enough to my bucket list that I don't think I'll be allowed to finally kick "it" until I'm about 162 years old!!

Well we got one coming up in July that I see you will be participating in.

coscorrosa · May 31, 2009

Agree with everyone else, that last one is great

One day I too shall be in the Canadian Rockies, hopefully sooner rather than later.

CWSkopec · June 1, 2009

dlplumer wrote:

Well we got one coming up in July that I see you will be participating in.

And July can't come soon enough!!

dlplumer · June 1, 2009

Jack'll do wrote:

That last one is simply GREAT Dan.thumb

Thanks Jack. I appreciate that very much

dlplumer · June 1, 2009

coscorrosa wrote:

Agree with everyone else, that last one is great

One day I too shall be in the Canadian Rockies, hopefully sooner rather than later.

Thanks Ron

Looking for some feedback

Comments