Same Photo...2 Edits

PhotoDavid78PhotoDavid78 Davidweissphotos.comLong IslandPosts: 906Registered Users Major grins

Here is the same photo of Indian Brook Falls in Garrison, NY with 2 different edits.
Can you please tell me which one you like better and why? Thank you!

1

2

David Weiss | Canon 5D Mark III | Pentax K10D | iPhone
My Website
Facebook | Twitter | | VSCOgrid | Instagram |

Comments

  • StumblebumStumblebum I shoot, therefore I am Posts: 7,593Registered Users Major grins

    They are not close......

    First one has light and warmth.....

    Second one is dull

  • PhotoDavid78PhotoDavid78 Davidweissphotos.com Long IslandPosts: 906Registered Users Major grins

    Here is a third edit. I think I like the color and light from 1 with the crop and depth of number 2.

    David Weiss | Canon 5D Mark III | Pentax K10D | iPhone
    My Website
    Facebook | Twitter | | VSCOgrid | Instagram |
  • StumblebumStumblebum I shoot, therefore I am Posts: 7,593Registered Users Major grins

    I agree, definitely depth adds to it more, so good idea to combine the best of both......the first has bit of 2d feel that third one removes. Fantastic capture either way.

  • CornflakeCornflake Major grins Posts: 2,441Registered Users Major grins

    The photos in your first post aren't showing up for me but I like your revision a lot.

  • PhotoDavid78PhotoDavid78 Davidweissphotos.com Long IslandPosts: 906Registered Users Major grins

    @Cornflake said:
    The photos in your first post aren't showing up for me but I like your revision a lot.

    oops. I deleted them from my website so it deleted it from here.

    David Weiss | Canon 5D Mark III | Pentax K10D | iPhone
    My Website
    Facebook | Twitter | | VSCOgrid | Instagram |
  • bfluegiebfluegie Big grins IndianaPosts: 442Registered Users Major grins

    I don't know what the first two looked like, but the third one rocks! The combination of the light and detail is a winner with me.

    ~~Barbara
Sign In or Register to comment.