So, who's on YOUR list for LPS #3?

indiegirl · April 15, 2007

Which are your top ten images from LPS #3? In the spirit of the game, don't include your own image (if you submitted), we all know you would vote for yourself, too! Feel free to come back and edit as needed. Here are mine tonight, in no particular order:

Mod edit:
wait till after the judges pick please

Andy · April 15, 2007

I think I'll delete this thread so that judges aren't influenced.

Sorry.

(And I'm a judge! I averted my eyes from your text).

indiegirl · April 15, 2007

I understand!

Jesse

Shay Stephens · April 15, 2007

Andy wrote:

I think I'll delete this thread so that judges aren't influenced.

Sorry.

(And I'm a judge! I averted my eyes from your text).

Don't go near the entry thread then, I hear it is full of posted photos. Oh and stay away from the "what do you think about this photo I took" threads, they have pictures and opinions to :nono

indiegirl · April 15, 2007

After thinking about this a bit more, I think the title of my post made the intention of the post clear and could easily be avoided by anyone who didn't want to be influenced.

I think this kind of discussion is a natural and postive outcome of the contest and should be nurtured, not micromanaged. I say this with the upmost respect, of course.

Jesse

sunione · April 15, 2007

interesting point

Shay Stephens wrote:

Don't go near the entry thread then, I hear it is full of posted photos. Oh and stay away from the "what do you think about this photo I took" threads, they have pictures and opinions to :nono

Shay....Good point. Most of the judges should just avoid reading any of the comments, but in Andy's case I think he has to read them as moderator?

richtersl · April 15, 2007

How about this:
After the judges have completed posting the results, can we start a thread where the rest of us can post our favorites -- kind of a Peoples Choice type of thing?

:ginger

Andy · April 15, 2007

sunione wrote:

Shay....Good point. Most of the judges should just avoid reading any of the comments, but in Andy's case I think he has to read them as moderator?

We're all moderators

I'm also a judge this round.

But so, let's say we have the thread stand- and someone gets in a fight over one shot or another or whatever... and we have to moderate. Then what

Talk all you like, we love it! But I personally think it's best to wait till after judge's picks.

indiegirl · April 15, 2007

richtersl wrote:

After the judges have completed posting the results, can we start a thread where the rest of us can post our favorites -- kind of a Peoples Choice type of thing?

:ginger

I think this is a good compromise.

indiegirl · April 16, 2007

I'm re-doing my list. There were some good late entries. Which ones are your favorites?

indiegirl · April 16, 2007

My favorites:

1. Teetering Travels
2. Fields of Gold
3. Down on the Farm
4. Clinging to Life
5. Dakota's Eyes
6. View from the Window
7. The Children's Fountain
8. Waiting
9. Luminescence
10. Eggs for Breakfast

intentional_noise · April 16, 2007

There are so many top quality shots!! I would dread being a judge and have to go through my list again in a while as there were 6 that have blown me way since I first saw them and still do - but another few I want to look at some more.

What a tough life, having to drool over these amazing images!

Well done everyone!

Nikolai · April 16, 2007

I got my ten in lps#3, but I guess I'll wait until the results are in...

It was rather easy this time, actually.
With so many entries, many of which were so nicely done, my logic was simple: I went through the list and picked up those I haven't had a slightest doubt about.
I ended up with 8 rock solid and 4-5 tossups, out of which I simply picked up the 2 I liked more at the moment.
Unfortunately, mine was not amongst those 8... :cry
Gotta work harder next time

salazar · April 16, 2007

I've picked mine but I'll wait too. It was easy not to pick mine, I didn't like it enough to enter it.

:

richtersl · April 16, 2007

I don't remember titles but two of my favorites were of dogs. One was the dog at the water fountain and the other was the one of the Border Collie (or Australian Shepherd) sitting on a rock with an absolutely gorgeous sky in the background.

urbanaries · April 16, 2007

this challenge was *so* dense with stellar entries, its anyone's guess who will get chosen.

indiegirl · April 16, 2007

I feel so exposed with my poor wee favorites sitting out there, all by themselves and lonesome.

Not asking who will get chosen, asking who were YOUR favorites? I totally dig why the judges aren't sharing their picks yet. The rest of you: commit, why don't ya?!

Jesse

photogmomma · April 16, 2007

I sat down to figure this out about 5 times and I keep getting distracted! Tough choices, but there are some really great ones!

intentional_noise · April 16, 2007

Ok for me

Teetering Travels
Broken Pattern
Poised Elegance
Clinging to Life
Follow the Light
Childrens Fountain - dog one
Lonely Times
Watercolour
Which way is up
Cracked Egg - I struggled with but it was my overall favorite, but the head does just say scenic with the word pocturesque, but it was a fabulous picturesque egg capture to me

davev · April 16, 2007

My top 10

Teetering travels #7
Untitled #21
Broken Pattern #29
Poised Elegance #41
Rural sunset #48
Blue Boston Ma #58
Children's Fountain #72
Waterfall #74
In Blue #75
Luminescence #88

I leaned more towards the pretty and less towards the odd.

eoren1 · April 16, 2007

I'll play the top-10 game.
Excluding mine (#58) which I hope makes it onto someone's list

9
13
20
21
46
50
52
68
73
77

E

ericgtr · April 16, 2007

I'll play too. In no particular order:

9 Fields of Gold
13 Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge (great job on WB)
24 Frosted Falls
34 Postcard
38 don't you just love Colorado?
42 Morning radiance, 6am
73 Waiting
76 The Individualist
94 More or Less
29 Broken Pattern

Robert · April 16, 2007

#87 Pizza Delivery
# 7 teetering travels
#66 Gnarly Wedge
#29 Broken Pattern
#57 ...perhaps more prunes...
# 3 all shook up
#73 Waiting
#56 Lemonscape
#85 Abandoned
#77 Lonely Times

amy wilburn · April 16, 2007

I'll put mine in, too...
...after the judges pick

Nikolai · April 16, 2007

OK, I think it's safe to post now without taking a risk of affecting any judge's decision... :-)

Here's my list of LPS#3 Top Ten in the order of submission.

There were other very decent shots, but hey, top ten is top ten, I had to cull the rest out, including myself

wxwax · April 16, 2007

I think the fact that Robert and Nikolai only have two in common says something about the quality of the entries... and the hard job the judges have.

Andy · April 16, 2007

The tabulo-tron 8000 needs a kick in the disk drive!

Swartzy · April 16, 2007

Heh, well one thing is for certain..

Nikolai wrote:

OK, I think it's safe to post now without taking a risk of affecting any judge's decision... :-)

Here's my list of LPS#3 Top Ten in the order of submission.
There were other very decent shots, but hey, top ten is top ten, I had to cull the rest out, including myself

I've got an awesome loon shot hanging in my office

amy wilburn · April 16, 2007

also in no particular order...
my faves:

DoctorIt · April 16, 2007

Andy wrote:

The tabulo-tron 8000 needs a kick in the disk drive!

ouch!

i'm done. happy now?

salazar · April 17, 2007

My favorites, in order submitted:

Fields of Gold
Linens from the Outlet
...don't you just love Colorado?
Gone to seed
"While you were sleeping (I was awake and dreaming)"
"...perhaps more prunes..."
Snowed In in April
Waiting
Waterfall
Luminescence:

I actually picked quite a few more but this is a top ten list. Many great shot this time around. All are chosen less for technical reasons and more on the fact they got a reaction out of me, be it a smile each time I look at them, or a Wow! or a sense of peace. Great work everyone!

PS: Looks like the judges agreed with three of mine!

So, who's on YOUR list for LPS #3?

Comments