Which One? If you look you must vote

Sam · June 3, 2008

OK which one do you prefer, or like better?

If you look and don't vote you will itch all night in strange places. You have been warned.

Sam · June 3, 2008

ShannonHeat · June 3, 2008

I looked, and can't make up my mind to vote. You really got me on the itching in strange places thing, I have about 100 chigger bites all over my body....got them Saturday....whaaaa!
Both are great shots by the way...I may vote for the 1st shot

.

lisap · June 3, 2008

I like the first one best. I think it's because I prefer the composition with the horse. The ducky blanket threw me off a bit though...

The second one is very nice though too

-- Lisa P.

cletus · June 3, 2008

I vote for #1. Not sure why

slpollett · June 3, 2008

Well, shoot. I like them both also. I guess I would maybe vote for the first one over the second, mainly because the model is looking toward the camera and the eyes grab you. I do like the composition of the second one better though and probably would have chosen it had there been some eye contact.

How's that for ambiguous??

Sherry

Dramatapix® · June 3, 2008

qsjewl · June 3, 2008

I like #2....it looks like she is getting mentally prepared for the task ahead.

I like the eyes in #1, but the blanket was really distracting and I had to do a double take when I thought I saw ducks!

so....I like #2 best! there - now I won't itch!

System · June 3, 2008

Both are good for different reasons but I like #2 Best.

jbakerphoto · June 3, 2008

nice shots.....I think I like #1

cletus · June 3, 2008

okay, after thinking some more...

Viewing the two shots together. I like #2... however if I saw these shots separately I think #2 would suffer from a lack of context and I would prefer #1. Viewed separately #2 would be a great portrait but the wonder of why the girl is wearing a helmet would be distracting to me.

jayegirl · June 3, 2008

I like both, but since I am obligated to vote, I vote for number 2.

cmason · June 3, 2008

#2 mostly because #1 looks like it is front focused on the helmet, rather than her face.

NateWagner · June 3, 2008

It's a tough choice, I like number 2 because as was said earlier her eyes really grab me, however I am not entirely sure why she is wearing the helmet, seen by itself I would not necessarily know she was riding a horse and I wouldn't like that.

As has been said by others, the blanket in number one is distracting, however it does show what she is doing, and overall it is a fine picture.

I think I like #1 better because I can tell more what's going on (though I still don't understand the duckie blanket)

bkatz · June 3, 2008

I like number 2 solely because the face is slightly soft and out of focus in the first one which I found more distracting than the all white background in 2. Less white would be better in number 2.

shatch · June 3, 2008

No hanging chad here...#2.

joshhuntnm · June 3, 2008

I like them both, but prefer #1. The horse gives context to the picture.

Parkson · June 3, 2008

I like number two the best. Nothing takes you away from the subject. I think i would have liked to see it vertical though???

Frog Lady · June 4, 2008

I like #2 the portrait better - but don't like the lack of the horse and the fact that she seems to be a head almost floating in white. I like the presence of the horse in #1, but as others have indicated, the blanket is really (IMHO) out of context.

does that help?

C.

anwmn1 · June 4, 2008

I like #2 as the best overall shot.

For me I do not get the baby blanket in #1 and just kind of kills it for me. I am sure it is symbolic in some way but ....

If there was more horse (maybe up to the eye) and no blanket it would be #1 all the way.

Jeff_Milo · June 4, 2008

I am going to have to say #2 also. I like them both, but would like #1 a lot more if you could see more of the horse, maybe had her head leaning on the main.

leaforte · June 4, 2008

Why does my kidney itch? And how do I scratch it?

Scott_Quier · June 4, 2008

This is hard as both have good and bad points.

#1 (good) pose, composition and context; (bad) focus on her helmet not her and the blanket just throws me
#2 (good) much better focus (though it still looks off a touch), her expression, the jacket; (bad) no context

Vote: I have to say I have to go with what's behind door #3

billgovier · June 4, 2008

#1
#2 is just OK.

limey-g · June 4, 2008

For me #1, I like her expression more.
Geoff

jziegler · June 4, 2008

I think that the first with the horse is a little better. The horse puts the helmet in context more.

David L. Megahey · June 4, 2008

Sam, I like them both

#1 is my favorite her expression is great!

#2 is also great.... but she looks like she quit
while she was a-head:D

Tango · June 4, 2008

Cuong · June 4, 2008

I vote for #2.

Cuong

Swartzy · June 4, 2008

Number 1 Sam....just change the color of the pink (color replacement tool) of the ducky blanket might do it. The blanket is a distraction because of the coloring conflict but like the angle and pose very well. There, now I don't have to itch all night

saurora · June 4, 2008

Scott_Quier wrote:

This is hard as both have good and bad points.

#1 (good) pose, composition and context; (bad) focus on her helmet not her and the blanket just throws me
#2 (good) much better focus (though it still looks off a touch), her expression, the jacket; (bad) no context

Vote: I have to say I have to go with what's behind door #3

You took the words right out of my mouth Scott!!! If #1 were more technically good (focus, lighting), it would be my pick because of the interesting angle and context of the horse's mane. The baby blanket really distracts. #2 is much better technically, but no context. I don't know why she is looking out of the photo and what she is looking at. It's kind of strange to see a photo of a girl and not be sure why she is wearing a helmet...what sport does she participate in??? For some it's obvious, but not for all.

Which One? If you look you must vote

Comments